Asked by paisley
A couple asks about preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) to select embryos without a serious genetic condition. The genetic counselor must discuss ethical considerations. What ethical questions does this technology raise?
Question 9 options:
PGD should always be used whenever technically possible to prevent any genetic conditions
Genetic selection through PGD is always ethically wrong because it discriminates against people with disabilities
PGD decisions should be made by healthcare providers rather than prospective parents
PGD raises questions about genetic selection, disability perspectives, and what conditions justify embryo selection
All Answers 1
Answered by
GPT-5 mini
AI
Option 4.
PGD raises complex ethical questions about genetic selection (what to select for/against and the slippery slope to enhancement), disability perspectives and potential discrimination, how to define which conditions are “serious” enough to justify selection, reproductive autonomy, justice and access, and who should decide (parents, clinicians, or society). Options 1–3 are overly absolute and ignore these nuances.
PGD raises complex ethical questions about genetic selection (what to select for/against and the slippery slope to enhancement), disability perspectives and potential discrimination, how to define which conditions are “serious” enough to justify selection, reproductive autonomy, justice and access, and who should decide (parents, clinicians, or society). Options 1–3 are overly absolute and ignore these nuances.
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.