Asked by Fakie
Where can we expect to find strong Vander wheels for dispersion forces within a large molecule with a strong temporary dipole between neighboring molecules with small electric on clouds within a larger molecule with a weak temporary dipole or between neighboring molecules with large electron clouds
All Answers 1
Answered by
GPT-5 mini
AI
Short answer: where the electron clouds are largest and most easily distorted — i.e., between neighboring species (or parts of the same molecule) that have large, polarizable electron clouds and can get into close contact. Those give the strongest London (dispersion) forces.
Why:
- Dispersion forces arise from instantaneous/induced dipoles and scale with polarizability (how easily an electron cloud is distorted). Larger atoms/molecules with more electrons and more diffuse outer electrons are more polarizable → stronger dispersion.
- They also depend strongly on distance and contact area (roughly ∝ 1/r^6). Flat or elongated surfaces that can approach closely give larger dispersion than compact or highly branched shapes.
- Permanent or strong temporary dipoles can enhance attraction by induction or dipole–induced dipole effects, but a “strong temporary dipole” usually comes from a large, polarizable electron cloud anyway.
Examples and comparisons:
- Heavy noble gases: Xe ≫ Ar ≫ He (Xe has much stronger dispersion).
- Long, linear alkanes have stronger dispersion than equally massive but highly branched alkanes (more contact area).
- Aromatic rings and molecules with pi‑electron clouds are highly polarizable and give strong dispersion.
- Intramolecular dispersion can be significant when a large molecule folds so electron‑rich regions lie close together.
So of your listed options, the strongest dispersion is expected between neighboring molecules (or parts of a molecule) with large electron clouds (and/or when a large molecule has strongly polarizable regions that come into close contact). Small electron clouds or weakly polarizable fragments give much weaker dispersion.
Why:
- Dispersion forces arise from instantaneous/induced dipoles and scale with polarizability (how easily an electron cloud is distorted). Larger atoms/molecules with more electrons and more diffuse outer electrons are more polarizable → stronger dispersion.
- They also depend strongly on distance and contact area (roughly ∝ 1/r^6). Flat or elongated surfaces that can approach closely give larger dispersion than compact or highly branched shapes.
- Permanent or strong temporary dipoles can enhance attraction by induction or dipole–induced dipole effects, but a “strong temporary dipole” usually comes from a large, polarizable electron cloud anyway.
Examples and comparisons:
- Heavy noble gases: Xe ≫ Ar ≫ He (Xe has much stronger dispersion).
- Long, linear alkanes have stronger dispersion than equally massive but highly branched alkanes (more contact area).
- Aromatic rings and molecules with pi‑electron clouds are highly polarizable and give strong dispersion.
- Intramolecular dispersion can be significant when a large molecule folds so electron‑rich regions lie close together.
So of your listed options, the strongest dispersion is expected between neighboring molecules (or parts of a molecule) with large electron clouds (and/or when a large molecule has strongly polarizable regions that come into close contact). Small electron clouds or weakly polarizable fragments give much weaker dispersion.
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.