Question

Read the passage from an argumentative essay.

Many endangered species are currently threatened by climate change. There are some laws already in place, but are they effective enough? Anyone with a conscience knows that these creatures deserve the chance to survive without outside threats impeding their survival. I suppose this is a tough decision for lawmakers, but I hope they choose wisely.

Which statement best evaluates the claim in the passage?

The claim is ineffective because the language used is unclear and the reasoning does not strongly support it.
The claim is unsuccessful because most people will not agree with the opinion and reasoning stated in the claim.
The claim is logical because it makes sense and the reasoning used to support it is plausible, varied, and effective.
The claim is compelling because there is variety in the supporting evidence and the call to action is powerful.

Answer 1

The first statement. The passage relies on vague language and emotional appeal rather than clear, supported reasoning, so the claim is ineffective.