Question

My turn to be Joker, Harley and Riddler: hmm, U don't know this riddle,do you Riddler. Riddler: I can't think of A answer. Harley: oh boys, I think the answer, might be A Pumpkin..Joker: A pumpkin, I did not knew it until now. Riddler: Ok Gordon,our answer is A Pumpkin! Your turn to be Gordon

Answer 1

Gordon: Hmm, a pumpkin? Interesting choice, but that's not quite right. Let me give you a hint: I'm thinking of something that can be found in the dark, often used for tricks and treats. What might that be?