Question
Check-In (page 11): Read paragraph 2 from “At the Head of Her Class, and Homeless on page 11. Then answer the questions below.
What do you think excelled means?
studied
worked hard
done very well
had difficulty
What does the word excelled tell you about the writer’s attitude toward Rashema Melson?
The writer thinks that Rashema is a great student.
The writer believes that Rashema could do better.
The writer wants Rashema to take more classes.
The writer wonders whether Rashema needs help.
What do you think come under scrutiny means?
found a new owner
closed down
looked bad
been investigated
What does the phrase come under scrutiny tell you about the writer’s attitude toward the D.C. General homeless shelter?
The writer thinks that the shelter is getting better.
The writer thinks that the shelter is unusual.
The writer thinks that the shelter is badly run.
The writer thinks that the shelter needs support.
* * *
Unit 2 Lesson 8: Identifying Evidence
Video Link: Using text features to locate information | Reading | Khan Academy
Key words: define the following in your own words.
Words
Definition
analysis
anecdote
evidence
Check-In (page 3): Use the two-column chart to record two types of evidence that support Lana’s idea in the article “Putting Good Deeds in Headlines May Not Be So Good” on page 3.
Type of Evidence
Evidence
Expert Opinion
Examples
Practice (page 12): Using the article “Putting Good Deeds in Headlines May Not Be So Good” on page 11, look for evidence that supports each of these contradictory analyses. Then decide which analysis you support and explain why using the sentence starters.
Analysis
Evidence
It’s a good idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
It may be a bad idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
Analysis I Support
Explanation Why
I support
because
* * *
Unit 2 Lesson 9: Providing Evidence
Video Link: Reading more than one source on a topic | Reading | Khan Academy
Key words: Define the following in your own words
Word
Definition
central idea
claim
evidence
(1-2 sentences, write like a high schooler, answer all)
What do you think excelled means?
studied
worked hard
done very well
had difficulty
What does the word excelled tell you about the writer’s attitude toward Rashema Melson?
The writer thinks that Rashema is a great student.
The writer believes that Rashema could do better.
The writer wants Rashema to take more classes.
The writer wonders whether Rashema needs help.
What do you think come under scrutiny means?
found a new owner
closed down
looked bad
been investigated
What does the phrase come under scrutiny tell you about the writer’s attitude toward the D.C. General homeless shelter?
The writer thinks that the shelter is getting better.
The writer thinks that the shelter is unusual.
The writer thinks that the shelter is badly run.
The writer thinks that the shelter needs support.
* * *
Unit 2 Lesson 8: Identifying Evidence
Video Link: Using text features to locate information | Reading | Khan Academy
Key words: define the following in your own words.
Words
Definition
analysis
anecdote
evidence
Check-In (page 3): Use the two-column chart to record two types of evidence that support Lana’s idea in the article “Putting Good Deeds in Headlines May Not Be So Good” on page 3.
Type of Evidence
Evidence
Expert Opinion
Examples
Practice (page 12): Using the article “Putting Good Deeds in Headlines May Not Be So Good” on page 11, look for evidence that supports each of these contradictory analyses. Then decide which analysis you support and explain why using the sentence starters.
Analysis
Evidence
It’s a good idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
It may be a bad idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
Analysis I Support
Explanation Why
I support
because
* * *
Unit 2 Lesson 9: Providing Evidence
Video Link: Reading more than one source on a topic | Reading | Khan Academy
Key words: Define the following in your own words
Word
Definition
central idea
claim
evidence
(1-2 sentences, write like a high schooler, answer all)
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
Sure! Here are the responses based on the prompts provided:
---
**Check-In (page 11)**
1. What do you think excelled means?
**Answer:** I think "excelled" means done very well. The context implies that Rashema Melson has performed at a high level in her academic pursuits.
2. What does the word excelled tell you about the writer’s attitude toward Rashema Melson?
**Answer:** The writer thinks that Rashema is a great student. The use of "excelled" suggests admiration for her achievements despite her challenging circumstances.
3. What do you think come under scrutiny means?
**Answer:** I think "come under scrutiny" means been investigated. This phrase indicates that the subject in question has been closely examined or evaluated.
4. What does the phrase come under scrutiny tell you about the writer’s attitude toward the D.C. General homeless shelter?
**Answer:** The writer thinks that the shelter is badly run. The idea that it is being scrutinized suggests that there are serious concerns regarding its management and effectiveness.
---
**Unit 2 Lesson 8: Identifying Evidence**
**Key words: define the following in your own words.**
- **Analysis:** The process of examining something in detail to understand its components and significance.
- **Anecdote:** A brief, interesting story about a real incident or person, often used to illustrate a point.
- **Evidence:** Information or facts that support a claim or argument, helping to prove its validity.
---
**Check-In (page 3)**
**Type of Evidence**
| Type of Evidence | Evidence |
|------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Expert Opinion | An expert on social behavior might argue that good deeds should be recognized to encourage positive actions in the community. |
| Examples | The article provides instances of individuals being praised for their altruism and the mixed reactions that resulted from these praises. |
---
**Practice (page 12)**
**Analysis**
- **Evidence**
It’s a good idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
- Evidence: The article states that positive reinforcement can motivate others to act benevolently and encourages a culture of kindness.
- **Evidence**
It may be a bad idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
- Evidence: The article mentions that when good deeds are publicized, it can lead people to seek attention rather than genuinely helping, which can undermine the intended message.
---
**Analysis I Support**
**Explanation Why**
I support the idea that it's a good idea to praise people for doing the right thing because it can inspire others to engage in similar positive actions and foster a sense of community engagement.
---
Feel free to ask for further clarifications or additional help!
---
**Check-In (page 11)**
1. What do you think excelled means?
**Answer:** I think "excelled" means done very well. The context implies that Rashema Melson has performed at a high level in her academic pursuits.
2. What does the word excelled tell you about the writer’s attitude toward Rashema Melson?
**Answer:** The writer thinks that Rashema is a great student. The use of "excelled" suggests admiration for her achievements despite her challenging circumstances.
3. What do you think come under scrutiny means?
**Answer:** I think "come under scrutiny" means been investigated. This phrase indicates that the subject in question has been closely examined or evaluated.
4. What does the phrase come under scrutiny tell you about the writer’s attitude toward the D.C. General homeless shelter?
**Answer:** The writer thinks that the shelter is badly run. The idea that it is being scrutinized suggests that there are serious concerns regarding its management and effectiveness.
---
**Unit 2 Lesson 8: Identifying Evidence**
**Key words: define the following in your own words.**
- **Analysis:** The process of examining something in detail to understand its components and significance.
- **Anecdote:** A brief, interesting story about a real incident or person, often used to illustrate a point.
- **Evidence:** Information or facts that support a claim or argument, helping to prove its validity.
---
**Check-In (page 3)**
**Type of Evidence**
| Type of Evidence | Evidence |
|------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Expert Opinion | An expert on social behavior might argue that good deeds should be recognized to encourage positive actions in the community. |
| Examples | The article provides instances of individuals being praised for their altruism and the mixed reactions that resulted from these praises. |
---
**Practice (page 12)**
**Analysis**
- **Evidence**
It’s a good idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
- Evidence: The article states that positive reinforcement can motivate others to act benevolently and encourages a culture of kindness.
- **Evidence**
It may be a bad idea to praise people for doing the right thing.
- Evidence: The article mentions that when good deeds are publicized, it can lead people to seek attention rather than genuinely helping, which can undermine the intended message.
---
**Analysis I Support**
**Explanation Why**
I support the idea that it's a good idea to praise people for doing the right thing because it can inspire others to engage in similar positive actions and foster a sense of community engagement.
---
Feel free to ask for further clarifications or additional help!