Question
Your friend runs into your room and shows you the latest TikTok video. Plant-e-man (@plant.e.man) explains how you can save money and the environment by stopping eating food altogether! He has discovered a way for humans to create their own food by photosynthesis! He calls it the "make it or die" challenge. As you keep watching the video you see the ending where Plant-e-man says "It takes about 2 months to kickstart your body and those suck! But I've been doing this for 6 months and feel better than I have ever felt before!" Your friend is so excited!
Write the conversation you will have with your friend. Make sure to not just talk about but explain reliable resources including the words "peer reviewed" and "validity".
To earn full credit:
A: Explain the importance of reliable sources using the words peer-reviewed and validity.
B: Define the words peer-reviewed and validity.
C: Answer in a conversational style.
Write the conversation you will have with your friend. Make sure to not just talk about but explain reliable resources including the words "peer reviewed" and "validity".
To earn full credit:
A: Explain the importance of reliable sources using the words peer-reviewed and validity.
B: Define the words peer-reviewed and validity.
C: Answer in a conversational style.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
**You:** Wow, that TikTok video is pretty wild! I mean, the idea of doing photosynthesis like plants sounds intriguing, but we should really think about it critically.
**Friend:** But he looks so healthy! He says he feels amazing. Why wouldn’t this work?
**You:** I get that, but we need to consider where the information is coming from. Reliable sources are super important when it comes to health claims. For example, any scientific claims should ideally be backed by peer-reviewed studies.
**Friend:** What do you mean by peer-reviewed?
**You:** Good question! Peer-reviewed means that a group of experts in a particular field has evaluated the research before it gets published. This process checks for accuracy, validity, and rigor in the methodology, which helps ensure that the findings are trustworthy.
**Friend:** And what do you mean by validity?
**You:** Validity refers to how well a study measures what it’s supposed to measure. For instance, if a study claims that humans can survive on photosynthesis, we need to ask if they’ve conducted controlled experiments and gathered enough evidence to support that claim. If the validity is high, we can trust the conclusions they draw.
**Friend:** So you’re saying just because someone feels good on TikTok doesn’t mean it’s scientifically sound?
**You:** Exactly! Anecdotal evidence—like someone feeling great after making a drastic lifestyle change—can be misleading. That doesn’t mean it works for everyone, or that it won’t have negative effects. We should look for studies that have been peer-reviewed for that stronger evidence.
**Friend:** Makes sense! I guess it’s better to wait for more information before jumping into something like this.
**You:** Definitely! It’s crucial to do our research and ensure that the methods we consider are backed by solid evidence. Who knows? Maybe there are better ways to save money and the environment that are proven to be safe and effective!
**Friend:** But he looks so healthy! He says he feels amazing. Why wouldn’t this work?
**You:** I get that, but we need to consider where the information is coming from. Reliable sources are super important when it comes to health claims. For example, any scientific claims should ideally be backed by peer-reviewed studies.
**Friend:** What do you mean by peer-reviewed?
**You:** Good question! Peer-reviewed means that a group of experts in a particular field has evaluated the research before it gets published. This process checks for accuracy, validity, and rigor in the methodology, which helps ensure that the findings are trustworthy.
**Friend:** And what do you mean by validity?
**You:** Validity refers to how well a study measures what it’s supposed to measure. For instance, if a study claims that humans can survive on photosynthesis, we need to ask if they’ve conducted controlled experiments and gathered enough evidence to support that claim. If the validity is high, we can trust the conclusions they draw.
**Friend:** So you’re saying just because someone feels good on TikTok doesn’t mean it’s scientifically sound?
**You:** Exactly! Anecdotal evidence—like someone feeling great after making a drastic lifestyle change—can be misleading. That doesn’t mean it works for everyone, or that it won’t have negative effects. We should look for studies that have been peer-reviewed for that stronger evidence.
**Friend:** Makes sense! I guess it’s better to wait for more information before jumping into something like this.
**You:** Definitely! It’s crucial to do our research and ensure that the methods we consider are backed by solid evidence. Who knows? Maybe there are better ways to save money and the environment that are proven to be safe and effective!