Sourcing Document B
Who wrote this?
The excerpt is attributed to Steve Greenberg, who is a reporter for VC Reporter, although the phrase itself is famously derived from the Declaration of Independence written by Thomas Jefferson in 1776.
When was it written?
The publication date is March 22, 2010, for the article in VC Reporter. The original phrase from the Declaration of Independence was written in 1776.
Where was it written?
The excerpt appeared in VC Reporter, which is a publication based in Ventura, CA.
Why was it written?
The excerpt likely aims to discuss or reflect on the philosophical and historical significance of the concepts of "Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness" in the context of American values, possibly relating them to contemporary issues or discussions about rights and freedoms.
Is it reliable? Why? Why not?
The reliability of the document can be considered with the following points:
-
Authority: Steve Greenberg is a journalist, but he is not a noted historian or constitutional scholar. However, he is a reporter and likely provides a reflection or interpretation of well-known concepts.
-
Context: Given that the initial quote is from a foundational American document (the Declaration of Independence), the reliability of the content regarding the ideals of life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness is strong in the historical context. However, the interpretation and application to modern issues may vary based on personal beliefs and biases.
-
Date: The article is from 2010, meaning it reflects a contemporary interpretation of these principles, which may also add a layer of subjectivity based on current societal issues of that time.
Overall, while the original phrase is a reliable historical statement, the modern commentary from Greenberg may reflect personal views and opinions about these rights, thus requiring careful consideration of context and purpose.