To determine if the student's concluding statement regarding Wegener’s "puzzle piece" theory is supported by the text about banded iron formations found on cratons, we need to analyze the content of the text for relevant evidence.
Evidence Supporting or Arguing Against the Statement:
-
Evidence from Geological Distribution: If the text discusses the distribution of banded iron formations and how they align with geological features across continents, this would support the idea that these formations are part of the evidence for continental drift and the breakup of Pangaea. For example, if the text mentions that similar banded iron formations are found on cratons of different continents that are now widely separated, it would indicate a historical connection, reinforcing Wegener's theory.
-
Evidence Refuting a Direct Link: Conversely, if the text explains that the formation of banded iron formations is due to specific geological processes that are not directly tied to continental drift (e.g., oceanic conditions rather than continental positioning), it would argue against the statement. For instance, if it details how certain environmental factors led to the creation of these formations independently of the movement of continents, this would weaken the claim made by the student.
Explanation of How Evidence Relates to the Conclusion:
-
If the geological distribution of banded iron formations aligns with Wegener's proposed patterns of continental movement, it reinforces the student's conclusion by providing concrete examples of how evidence of past connections between these landmasses exist.
-
Conversely, if the text focuses on the independent formation of banded iron without linking it back to continental arrangements and movement, then it serves to argue against the notion that this specific evidence supports Wegener's theory, suggesting that while it may show ancient processes, it does not directly validate the breakup of Pangaea.
In summary, the assessment of the student's statement hinges on specific details in the text regarding how banded iron formations relate to continental drift and Wegener's theory.