Question
Use the claim to answer the question.
Claim: People should purchase electric vehicles because, unlike gasoline-powered vehicles, they do not harm the environment.
Which counterclaim is fair?
(1 point)
Responses
People should not purchase electric vehicles because the electricity used to charge them creates carbon pollution.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because the electricity used to charge them creates carbon pollution.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because they are only available in a limited number of colors and models.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because they are only available in a limited number of colors and models.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because there are still very few locations where these vehicles can be charged.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because there are still very few locations where these vehicles can be charged.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because deciding what is environmentally friendly is a subjective process.
Claim: People should purchase electric vehicles because, unlike gasoline-powered vehicles, they do not harm the environment.
Which counterclaim is fair?
(1 point)
Responses
People should not purchase electric vehicles because the electricity used to charge them creates carbon pollution.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because the electricity used to charge them creates carbon pollution.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because they are only available in a limited number of colors and models.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because they are only available in a limited number of colors and models.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because there are still very few locations where these vehicles can be charged.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because there are still very few locations where these vehicles can be charged.
People should not purchase electric vehicles because deciding what is environmentally friendly is a subjective process.
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
The fair counterclaim is:
**People should not purchase electric vehicles because the electricity used to charge them creates carbon pollution.**
This counterclaim directly addresses the environmental impact of electric vehicles, specifically in relation to the claim that they do not harm the environment.
**People should not purchase electric vehicles because the electricity used to charge them creates carbon pollution.**
This counterclaim directly addresses the environmental impact of electric vehicles, specifically in relation to the claim that they do not harm the environment.