The statement "All of the following options are benefits we receive as a result of government spending EXCEPT…" implies that you are looking for an option that does not represent a benefit directly associated with government spending.
Based on the options provided:
A. Health and retirement benefits for seniors - This is a direct benefit of government spending, particularly through programs like Social Security and Medicare.
B. Credit card debt forgiveness - This is not typically a benefit resulting from regular government spending. While governments can implement policies regarding debt relief, it is not a standard government service funded through typical government expenditures.
C. National parks maintenance - This is a benefit of government spending as it involves funds allocated to maintain and protect national parks.
D. Public school education - Public education is directly funded by government spending at various levels (local, state, federal).
Thus, the option that does not represent a benefit directly related to government spending is:
B. Credit card debt forgiveness.