It sounds like you've identified two compelling positions that leverage your skills and interests in operations, leadership, and efficiency. Your comparison of the Area Manager role at Amazon and the Manager of Central Supply at UnityPoint Health highlights a focus on internal processes and decision-making, which is indeed aligned with managerial accounting.
When discussing what peers found interesting about their chosen positions, it can often reveal diverse perspectives on the value and application of accounting skills. Some may gravitate towards roles that emphasize external financial reporting and compliance, appreciating the structure and rigor of financial accounting as it pertains to investor relations or regulatory requirements. Others, like you, may be drawn to positions that prioritize internal efficiency and strategic planning.
In terms of the comparison between managerial and financial accounting, I would agree with your observations. Managerial accounting is oriented towards providing information that aids in operational decision-making, cost control, and performance measurement, while financial accounting is focused more on historical financial data and its presentation to external stakeholders. Your emphasis on internal planning and efficiency resonates well with the intent behind managerial accounting, making it crucial in roles like those you're considering.
Ultimately, the appeal of roles significantly depends on individual interests and career aspirations, whether one aligns more with operational efficiency or external financial scrutiny. It sounds like you're leaning towards positions that not only challenge you but also allow you to make a tangible impact in the organizations you work for.