Question

For this assignment, you will conduct research and evaluate how various roads that have been built in
rainforests impact people and the Earth. Based on your research and evaluation, you will write a position
paper expressing whether you are for or against the building of roads in rainforests. Then, you will share
and discuss with your peers your position. Write a position paper that is three paragraphs and write it like an 8th grader. After write a group discussion and evaluation that is happening between me, Lucius, and James about my position and write it like an 8th grader.

Answer 1

**Position Paper: The Impact of Roads in Rainforests**

Building roads in rainforests can be a controversial topic. On one hand, some people argue that roads are necessary for development. They say roads can help provide better access to remote areas for healthcare, education, and jobs. When roads are built, it becomes easier for people to transport goods, and it can also lead to economic growth. For example, having a road could allow farmers to get their products to markets faster, which helps them earn more money and improve their quality of life.

However, I believe the negative impacts of building roads in rainforests outweigh the positives. Rainforests are home to countless species of plants and animals, many of which are endangered. When roads are built, they can lead to deforestation, hurting these habitats and the creatures that depend on them. The construction of roads can also encourage illegal activities like logging and mining, which further damage the environment. Additionally, native communities that have lived in the rainforest for generations often find their homes and ways of life disrupted by road-building. This can lead to loss of culture and livelihoods for these communities, which is very unfair.

In conclusion, while roads may bring some benefits, the harm they cause to the environment and local communities is too great. Protecting our rainforests should be a priority, as they are vital for the Earth’s health. Instead of building more roads, we should focus on finding ways to support development that do not destroy nature. We need to protect the rainforests, not only for wildlife but also for future generations of people who could rely on their resources safely.

---

**Group Discussion: Evaluating My Position Paper**

**Lucius**: I read your position paper, and I think you made some great points! I agree that rainforests are really important for biodiversity and that building roads can cause a lot of harm. What do you think we should do instead of building roads, though?

**James**: Yeah, I was wondering about that too. I mean, it’s a tough situation. People do need access to services, and maybe there’s a way to compromise, like using smaller paths that don’t harm the forest as much? But I also get your point about protecting the environment.

**Me**: That’s a good question, Lucius and James! Instead of building big roads, I think we should look into other methods, like improving transportation through rivers or protecting existing paths. We could also help communities with eco-friendly options that support their needs without harming the forest.

**Lucius**: That's a solid idea! Eco-friendly options could mean creating jobs that focus on conserving the rainforest rather than destroying it. It really changes the narrative and could help local communities thrive without harming the environment.

**James**: Right! I really like how you brought up supporting local farmers and communities without damaging the rainforest. It’s exciting to think about how we could develop sustainable tourism or farming practices that would protect nature while providing for people.

**Me**: Exactly! It’s all about balance. If we can find ways to help people without ruining their environment, we can create a better future for everyone. Thanks for the feedback, guys; it really helped me think deeper about my position!