Question
1. Before Thorin dies in Chapter 18 of he reconciles with Bilbo. Why did Thorin change his mind?
2. In Chapter 18 of how does Dain's behavior contrast with Thorin's behavior with regard to the treasure?
2. In Chapter 18 of how does Dain's behavior contrast with Thorin's behavior with regard to the treasure?
Answers
GPT-4o mini
In Chapter 18 of "The Hobbit," Thorin Oakenshield undergoes a significant change of heart before his death, reconciling with Bilbo Baggins. Thorin initially exhibits a fierce protectiveness and greed over the treasure of the Lonely Mountain, which leads him to tensions with Bilbo and the other characters. However, as he lies on his deathbed after the Battle of the Five Armies, he realizes the futility of his obsession with the gold and the impact it has had on his relationships. He comes to understand the value of friendship and loyalty over wealth, leading him to apologize to Bilbo and acknowledge the merits of his actions throughout their journey together. Thorin's reconciliation signifies a moment of growth and the recognition of what truly matters beyond material possessions.
In contrast, Dain Ironfoot's behavior regarding the treasure reflects a more pragmatic and level-headed approach. Unlike Thorin, who becomes consumed by his desire for the treasure and becomes obstinate, Dain demonstrates a willingness to share and negotiate. After coming to the aid of the dwarves, he is more focused on the well-being of his people and the potential for peace rather than excessive greed. Dain understands the importance of unity and cooperation, especially in the face of external threats, and he seeks to find a solution that will benefit all parties involved. This contrast highlights the different attitudes toward wealth and leadership between Dain and Thorin, emphasizing Thorin's tragic flaw of pride and the eventual wisdom that emerges in the face of mortality.
In contrast, Dain Ironfoot's behavior regarding the treasure reflects a more pragmatic and level-headed approach. Unlike Thorin, who becomes consumed by his desire for the treasure and becomes obstinate, Dain demonstrates a willingness to share and negotiate. After coming to the aid of the dwarves, he is more focused on the well-being of his people and the potential for peace rather than excessive greed. Dain understands the importance of unity and cooperation, especially in the face of external threats, and he seeks to find a solution that will benefit all parties involved. This contrast highlights the different attitudes toward wealth and leadership between Dain and Thorin, emphasizing Thorin's tragic flaw of pride and the eventual wisdom that emerges in the face of mortality.