Understanding differing opinions on a topic is important because it fosters deeper conversations and encourages critical thinking. In the article “A teen and a trolley reveal society’s dark side,” the trolley dilemma illustrates how people's choices can reveal biases and moral complexities. Some may argue that people can be completely good based on their caring actions, while others point out that everyone has the potential for a “dark side,” shaped by mistakes and environmental factors. For instance, some classmates believed that making good choices indicates a lack of darkness, while others countered that our environment significantly influences behavior. By engaging with these varying perspectives, we can better appreciate the complexities of human nature and morality. This understanding not only enriches our discussions but also promotes empathy, as we can recognize the diverse experiences that shape individuals’ views. Ultimately, appreciating differing opinions helps to create a more inclusive and thoughtful society.
Earlier this unit, you read an article called “A teen and a trolley reveal society’s dark side” by Bethany Brookshire. Next, you participated in a discussion regarding “good vs. evil”, and whether people could be completely good, or whether everyone has a “dark side”. Below are the key ideas and differing perspectives from that discussion. Use the information below to answer the prompt at the bottom of this page.
Key Ideas:
People can be completely good because they often demonstrate that they genuinely care about others.
All people have a dark side because in the case of the trolley, the article shows us that people often have certain biases that help create their choices.
Differing Perspectives:
Some people in the group felt that people could be completely good because they make good choices and stay out of trouble.
Some people felt that no one can be “completely” good, but it doesn’t necessarily mean they have a “dark side”.
Some people in the group felt that all people have a dark side; a part of being human means making mistakes and sometimes making the wrong decisions.
Some people felt that all people have a dark side because how you behave depends on the environment you are raised in and how you were taught to behave.
Prompt for Portfolio:
You have read the article "A teen and a trolley reveal society’s dark side” , and above you can see the key ideas and differing perspectives of your classmates. Based on this information, write a paragraph answering this prompt:
Why it is important to have, and to understand, differing opinions on a topic? Use examples from the article and/or the various ideas presented from the discussion to help support your thinking. (answer in a paragraph of at least 5-6 sentences, using appropriate punctuation, capitalization, and formal language)
(20 points
please right it simply
1 answer