Here’s how to categorize the arguments for and against each theory about the source of Earth's water:
Evidence for:
- Comets: Spacecraft have confirmed that objects from the Oort Cloud have non-Earth-like water.
- Asteroids: Spacecraft have confirmed that objects from the Kuiper Belt have Earth-like water.
- Solar Nebula: Others like it in the galaxy have water in their dust and gases.
Evidence against:
- Comets: Very little water is found on/in these objects.
- Asteroids: Very little water is found on/in these objects.
- Solar Nebula: The sun could have evaporated the water over the billions of years since Earth’s formation.
Feel free to ask if you need further clarification!