The correct answer is D: No, the water situated above the earthquake remained stationary, with only the energy being transferred.
This explanation is accurate because during a tsunami, the wave is a transfer of energy rather than a mass transport of the water itself. The water above the earthquake does not move directly to the island; instead, energy from the seismic event travels through the water column, creating the wave that moves across the ocean. The individual water particles mostly move in orbital motions, but they do not travel in a straight line to the distant land, leading to the tsunami impacting the island.