Question
Prosperity depression and world war 2 practice
How did president Hoovers approach toward the economy compare with Calvin Coolidge approach?
How did president Hoovers approach toward the economy compare with Calvin Coolidge approach?
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
President Herbert Hoover and President Calvin Coolidge had different approaches to the economy, shaped by their respective beliefs about government intervention, economic policy, and the role of federal government in managing economic issues.
### Calvin Coolidge (1923-1929):
1. **Laissez-Faire Philosophy**: Coolidge adhered to a laissez-faire economic philosophy, believing that minimal government intervention in the economy promotes individual initiative and economic growth. He famously said, "The business of America is business," reflecting his view that the government should not interfere excessively in economic matters.
2. **Tax Cuts and Budget Surplus**: Under Coolidge, the government focused on reducing taxes (including significant tax cuts for the wealthy) and maintaining a budget surplus. The administration believed that lower taxes would stimulate investment and economic growth.
3. **Minimal Regulation**: Coolidge's administration was characterized by minimal regulatory oversight, particularly of businesses and financial institutions. He trusted that the economy would self-correct without significant government involvement.
4. **Economic Growth**: The period of Coolidge's presidency was marked by a booming economy and significant industrial growth, contributing to the prosperity of the 1920s.
### Herbert Hoover (1929-1933):
1. **Initial Response to the Economy**: Hoover initially believed in voluntary cooperation between businesses and the government to maintain economic stability. He encouraged businesses not to cut wages or production, hoping to avert the economic downturn.
2. **Public Works Programs**: As the Great Depression deepened, Hoover increased government intervention to some extent by promoting public works projects, such as the construction of the Hoover Dam, to create jobs and stimulate economic activity.
3. **Limited Government Intervention**: Despite some initiatives, Hoover remained committed to limited government intervention. He believed that the economy would eventually recover on its own, which led to criticism as the depression worsened.
4. **Reluctance to Provide Direct Relief**: Hoover was generally reluctant to provide direct federal assistance to individuals, believing that such measures could undermine self-reliance and individual responsibility.
### Comparison:
- **Philosophy**: While both presidents favored limited government intervention, Coolidge was much more ideologically aligned with laissez-faire economics, whereas Hoover's early responses were more moderate, advocating voluntary cooperation and limited efforts at intervention.
- **Crisis Management**: Coolidge presided over a period of prosperity, implementing policies that fostered economic growth. In contrast, Hoover faced the Great Depression, leading to a shift in his stance toward more public works and limited government action, though he was still criticized for not doing enough.
- **Perception of Government's Role**: Coolidge viewed government as a facilitator of business, while Hoover's belief in limited intervention conflicted with the need for more active measures to address the economic crisis.
In summary, while both leaders maintained a belief in limited government intervention, Coolidge embraced a strictly hands-off approach during a period of growth, whereas Hoover's presidency required responses to a significant economic downturn, revealing a gap between his initial philosophy and the demands of the Great Depression.
### Calvin Coolidge (1923-1929):
1. **Laissez-Faire Philosophy**: Coolidge adhered to a laissez-faire economic philosophy, believing that minimal government intervention in the economy promotes individual initiative and economic growth. He famously said, "The business of America is business," reflecting his view that the government should not interfere excessively in economic matters.
2. **Tax Cuts and Budget Surplus**: Under Coolidge, the government focused on reducing taxes (including significant tax cuts for the wealthy) and maintaining a budget surplus. The administration believed that lower taxes would stimulate investment and economic growth.
3. **Minimal Regulation**: Coolidge's administration was characterized by minimal regulatory oversight, particularly of businesses and financial institutions. He trusted that the economy would self-correct without significant government involvement.
4. **Economic Growth**: The period of Coolidge's presidency was marked by a booming economy and significant industrial growth, contributing to the prosperity of the 1920s.
### Herbert Hoover (1929-1933):
1. **Initial Response to the Economy**: Hoover initially believed in voluntary cooperation between businesses and the government to maintain economic stability. He encouraged businesses not to cut wages or production, hoping to avert the economic downturn.
2. **Public Works Programs**: As the Great Depression deepened, Hoover increased government intervention to some extent by promoting public works projects, such as the construction of the Hoover Dam, to create jobs and stimulate economic activity.
3. **Limited Government Intervention**: Despite some initiatives, Hoover remained committed to limited government intervention. He believed that the economy would eventually recover on its own, which led to criticism as the depression worsened.
4. **Reluctance to Provide Direct Relief**: Hoover was generally reluctant to provide direct federal assistance to individuals, believing that such measures could undermine self-reliance and individual responsibility.
### Comparison:
- **Philosophy**: While both presidents favored limited government intervention, Coolidge was much more ideologically aligned with laissez-faire economics, whereas Hoover's early responses were more moderate, advocating voluntary cooperation and limited efforts at intervention.
- **Crisis Management**: Coolidge presided over a period of prosperity, implementing policies that fostered economic growth. In contrast, Hoover faced the Great Depression, leading to a shift in his stance toward more public works and limited government action, though he was still criticized for not doing enough.
- **Perception of Government's Role**: Coolidge viewed government as a facilitator of business, while Hoover's belief in limited intervention conflicted with the need for more active measures to address the economic crisis.
In summary, while both leaders maintained a belief in limited government intervention, Coolidge embraced a strictly hands-off approach during a period of growth, whereas Hoover's presidency required responses to a significant economic downturn, revealing a gap between his initial philosophy and the demands of the Great Depression.