How do Thoreau and Brooks differ in their views of human nature?
Responses
Thoreau sees people as low and primitive, whereas Brooks sees them as heroic and able to rise to any challenge.
Thoreau sees people as low and primitive, whereas Brooks sees them as heroic and able to rise to any challenge.
Thoreau believes people are not meant to live in groups, but Brooks thinks people are at their best among others.
Thoreau believes people are not meant to live in groups, but Brooks thinks people are at their best among others.
Thoreau feels that deep down humans are noble, whereas Brooks thinks their primary concern is self-preservation.
Thoreau feels that deep down humans are noble, whereas Brooks thinks their primary concern is self-preservation.
Thoreau thinks that people need one another to survive, but Brooks feels that any person can be completely self-sufficient.
Thoreau thinks that people need one another to survive, but Brooks feels that any person can be completely self-sufficient.
Responses
Thoreau sees people as low and primitive, whereas Brooks sees them as heroic and able to rise to any challenge.
Thoreau sees people as low and primitive, whereas Brooks sees them as heroic and able to rise to any challenge.
Thoreau believes people are not meant to live in groups, but Brooks thinks people are at their best among others.
Thoreau believes people are not meant to live in groups, but Brooks thinks people are at their best among others.
Thoreau feels that deep down humans are noble, whereas Brooks thinks their primary concern is self-preservation.
Thoreau feels that deep down humans are noble, whereas Brooks thinks their primary concern is self-preservation.
Thoreau thinks that people need one another to survive, but Brooks feels that any person can be completely self-sufficient.
Thoreau thinks that people need one another to survive, but Brooks feels that any person can be completely self-sufficient.
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
The most accurate distinction between Thoreau and Brooks in their views of human nature would be:
**Thoreau feels that deep down humans are noble, whereas Brooks thinks their primary concern is self-preservation.**
Thoreau, often associated with transcendentalism, believed in the inherent goodness and nobility of individuals, emphasizing self-reliance and the idea that individuals can connect deeply with nature and their higher selves. In contrast, David Brooks tends to focus on the complexities of human nature, often highlighting the struggle between self-interest and altruism, suggesting that self-preservation can be a dominant motivator in human behavior.
While the other options capture elements of their philosophies, this option best represents the core difference in their views on human nature.
**Thoreau feels that deep down humans are noble, whereas Brooks thinks their primary concern is self-preservation.**
Thoreau, often associated with transcendentalism, believed in the inherent goodness and nobility of individuals, emphasizing self-reliance and the idea that individuals can connect deeply with nature and their higher selves. In contrast, David Brooks tends to focus on the complexities of human nature, often highlighting the struggle between self-interest and altruism, suggesting that self-preservation can be a dominant motivator in human behavior.
While the other options capture elements of their philosophies, this option best represents the core difference in their views on human nature.
There are no human answers yet. A form for humans to post answers is coming very soon!