Question

Step 1: Read the following:



“The Earth is Not for Sale: The Debate Over Globalization - A Reader’s Theater



Step 2: Pick five of the characters and tell us if they are for or against globalization including the supporting evidence.



Step 3: Give your point of view, what do you think of global trade?



Step 4: Submit your posting (include both step 2 and step 3 writings) and reply to 2 students. Remember that simple “I agree” statements will not earn points.



Grading Rubric



Student makes significant post where all prompts are considered.

60 points

Student replies to 2 classmates. While it is acceptable for the student to “agree” or “disagree”, it must be followed up with additional facts or an explanation. This also goes for “good job” remarks. Your replies must be able to further the discussion

Answer 1

### Step 2: Characters' Positions on Globalization

1. **Raj Patel (Activist)**: **Against Globalization**
- Raj argues that globalization leads to wider disparities between the wealthy and the poor. He supports this by sharing data illustrating how multinational corporations exploit labor in developing countries, leaving local economies disrupted and incapable of sustainable growth.

2. **Amartya Sen (Economist)**: **For Globalization**
- Amartya believes that globalization can improve quality of life and access to resources worldwide. He cites examples of reduced poverty rates in several countries attributed to global trade, emphasizing how interconnectedness can enable growth and innovation.

3. **Wangari Maathai (Environmentalist)**: **Against Globalization**
- Wangari opposes globalization primarily on environmental grounds. She highlights how global trade contributes to environmental degradation and deforestation, particularly in developing nations that prioritize economic gain over ecological sustainability.

4. **Thomas Friedman (Journalist)**: **For Globalization**
- Thomas advocates for globalization by highlighting its potential to foster democracy and cross-cultural exchange. He argues that as nations connect through trade and technology, they become more likely to adopt democratic values and practices.

5. **Noam Chomsky (Political Activist)**: **Against Globalization**
- Noam is critical of the way globalization often prioritizes corporate interests over human rights. He argues that trade agreements are often designed without regard for the welfare of local populations, leading to exploitation and loss of cultural identity.

### Step 3: My Point of View on Global Trade

In my opinion, global trade is a double-edged sword. On one hand, it has the potential to stimulate economic growth, promote cultural exchange, and reduce poverty in some regions. Countries that engage in trade can access a wider variety of goods and services and can benefit from innovation that comes from global competition. On the other hand, globalization can exacerbate inequalities, contribute to environmental harm, and threaten local cultures and industries.

Ultimately, I believe we need to approach globalization with caution and a critical eye. Policies should focus on creating a fairer system that prioritizes human rights, environmental sustainability, and equitable economic development. Encouraging responsible corporate practices and enforcing regulations that protect marginalized communities will be essential in balancing the benefits and drawbacks of global trade.

### Replies to Classmates

**Reply to Classmate 1**:
"I appreciate your insights on the benefits of globalization, especially regarding economic growth. However, it's also crucial to consider the implications for workers in developing nations. While global trade can boost economies, it often comes at a cost to labor rights and environmental standards. What solutions do you think can mitigate these issues while still embracing trade?"

**Reply to Classmate 2**:
"You raised an interesting point about local cultures being affected by globalization. I agree that cultural homogenization is a valid concern. Nations should actively work into protecting their heritage while engaging in global trade. What strategies do you think could promote cultural preservation in the face of increasing globalization?"