How do artificial selection ans natural selection differ?

Artificial selection can alter genes directly
Artificial selection is random while natural selection is controls
Both selection types have unpredictable outcomes
Natural selections can only affect traits present in a population

1 answer

Artificial selection and natural selection are two processes that lead to changes in the genetic makeup of a population, but they differ in important ways:

  1. Agent of Selection:

    • Artificial Selection: This is a process where humans intentionally select specific traits in organisms for breeding. For example, farmers may breed plants or animals for desirable traits like size, color, or yield.
    • Natural Selection: This is a process that occurs in nature without human intervention. It favors organisms that are better suited to their environment, allowing them to survive and reproduce more successfully.
  2. Intent:

    • Artificial Selection: Humans have a specific goal in mind when selecting traits. The selection is directed towards achieving a certain outcome.
    • Natural Selection: There is no purposeful direction; it occurs based on environmental pressures and the individuals best adapted to those conditions tend to survive and reproduce.
  3. Outcome:

    • Artificial Selection: The outcomes are often predictable because they are guided by human choice and can lead to significant changes in a relatively short period.
    • Natural Selection: The outcomes are less predictable and can result in gradual changes over longer periods, influenced by changing environmental factors.
  4. Variation:

    • Both selection types can affect the variation present in a population, but natural selection does so by working on traits that are already present in the gene pool and can only modify those, while artificial selection may introduce new forms or exaggerated traits based on human preferences.

In summary, while both forms of selection can lead to evolutionary changes, they operate under different principles and agents.