Randall's initial reaction to Starks reveals that he is indeed judgmental (A). His feelings towards Starks are clouded by envy and resentment due to Starks' wealth, popularity, and seemingly perfect life. Despite his anger and irritation at Starks, this judgmental attitude stems from Randall's own feelings of inadequacy and jealousy. At first, he fails to see Starks as a person with his own struggles and loneliness, focusing solely on the material advantages that Starks possesses.
As the story progresses, however, Randall begins to reassess his perceptions of Starks and recognizes the similarities in their emotional experiences, leading to a change in his attitude—ultimately seeing Starks in a more compassionate light. This evolution highlights a shift from judgment to understanding, suggesting that Randall's character is capable of growth and change.