Question
4. Computer viruses are programs that, among other actions, can delete files without a user’s
permission. EFDR. legislator wrote a law banning the deletion of any files from computer disks.
What was the problem with this law from a computer security point of view? Specifically, state
which security service would have been affected if the law had been passed
permission. EFDR. legislator wrote a law banning the deletion of any files from computer disks.
What was the problem with this law from a computer security point of view? Specifically, state
which security service would have been affected if the law had been passed
Answers
GPT-4o mini
The law proposed by the EFDR legislator, which bans the deletion of any files from computer disks, presents significant problems from a computer security perspective, particularly regarding the principle of **data integrity**.
**Data integrity** refers to the accuracy and consistency of data over its lifecycle. A law that prevents the deletion of any files could compromise this principle because:
1. **Malicious Software**: Computer viruses or other malware often rely on the ability to delete or alter files to perform their actions. By prohibiting file deletion entirely, the law could inadvertently protect harmful files, such as malware, that need to be removed for the system to function correctly.
2. **Accidental Deletion**: Users or systems may need to delete files for legitimate reasons, such as removing outdated software, clearing up space, or fixing errors. A blanket ban could inhibit these necessary actions, leading to system inefficiencies and potential security risks.
3. **No Recovery from Compromise**: In the event of a data breach or compromise, the inability to delete compromised files could prevent effective remediation efforts. Security professionals may need to delete malicious files as part of forensic investigations, and the law would severely hinder these capabilities.
Therefore, if the law had been passed, the **security service affected** would primarily be **data integrity**, as it would limit the ability to manage, correct, and protect the system and data effectively.
**Data integrity** refers to the accuracy and consistency of data over its lifecycle. A law that prevents the deletion of any files could compromise this principle because:
1. **Malicious Software**: Computer viruses or other malware often rely on the ability to delete or alter files to perform their actions. By prohibiting file deletion entirely, the law could inadvertently protect harmful files, such as malware, that need to be removed for the system to function correctly.
2. **Accidental Deletion**: Users or systems may need to delete files for legitimate reasons, such as removing outdated software, clearing up space, or fixing errors. A blanket ban could inhibit these necessary actions, leading to system inefficiencies and potential security risks.
3. **No Recovery from Compromise**: In the event of a data breach or compromise, the inability to delete compromised files could prevent effective remediation efforts. Security professionals may need to delete malicious files as part of forensic investigations, and the law would severely hinder these capabilities.
Therefore, if the law had been passed, the **security service affected** would primarily be **data integrity**, as it would limit the ability to manage, correct, and protect the system and data effectively.