The correct conclusion the student could draw based on the masses he measured is:
C. The liquid formed from a melted solid has the same mass as the solid has.
When ice melts into water, the mass remains the same, assuming there is no loss of water (for example, through evaporation or spillage) since the container is tightly sealed. The law of conservation of mass states that mass is neither created nor destroyed in a closed system during a change of state.