Evolution by natural selection occurs when there is variation in traits among individuals in a population, where those traits can affect survival and reproduction, leading to changes in the frequency of those traits over generations.
In the scenarios provided, the only one that fits this definition is:
Penguins reproduce sexually, producing offspring that look different from one another.
This scenario involves sexual reproduction, which introduces genetic variation among the offspring. Some offspring may have traits that help them survive and reproduce better in their environment than others, which is the essence of natural selection. The other scenarios involve asexual reproduction or cloning, which do not create genetic diversity and thus do not typically lead to evolution by natural selection.