Question
Read the claim and counterclaim about the New Deal.
Supporters of President Roosevelt’s New Deal believed that it was necessary to alleviate rising unemployment rates. Conservative critics, however, claimed that there was too much taxation and government regulation.
Which rebuttal refutes the counterclaim?
Increased business taxes caused political unrest throughout the country.
Government regulation prevented the economy from continuing to plummet.
Unemployment rates remained high despite increased government regulation.
Businesses were being taxed at a higher rate than they had been prior to the Great Depression.
Supporters of President Roosevelt’s New Deal believed that it was necessary to alleviate rising unemployment rates. Conservative critics, however, claimed that there was too much taxation and government regulation.
Which rebuttal refutes the counterclaim?
Increased business taxes caused political unrest throughout the country.
Government regulation prevented the economy from continuing to plummet.
Unemployment rates remained high despite increased government regulation.
Businesses were being taxed at a higher rate than they had been prior to the Great Depression.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
The rebuttal that best refutes the counterclaim is:
**Government regulation prevented the economy from continuing to plummet.**
This response directly addresses the conservative critics' argument about government regulation by emphasizing that such regulation was essential in stabilizing the economy, thereby countering the claim that regulation was overly burdensome or detrimental.
**Government regulation prevented the economy from continuing to plummet.**
This response directly addresses the conservative critics' argument about government regulation by emphasizing that such regulation was essential in stabilizing the economy, thereby countering the claim that regulation was overly burdensome or detrimental.