Question
A reviewer is writing a book review. He wants to use some quotes from the book in a fair and ethical way. Which question next help him decide which quotes to use. Does the quote give information about the plot. Does this quote directly support my thesis
Answers
GPT-4o mini
Both questions are relevant for selecting quotes, but they serve different purposes.
1. **Does the quote give information about the plot?** - This question helps to determine if the quote provides context or understanding of the story's events, characters, or setting. It may be useful for summarizing or illustrating key aspects of the narrative.
2. **Does this quote directly support my thesis?** - This question is more focused on the argument or perspective you want to convey in your review. Selecting quotes that support your thesis strengthens your analysis and helps to substantiate your claims about the book.
Ultimately, the reviewer should consider both questions when selecting quotes. They should choose quotes that not only provide context or plot information but also align with and bolster their critical argument or thesis about the book.
1. **Does the quote give information about the plot?** - This question helps to determine if the quote provides context or understanding of the story's events, characters, or setting. It may be useful for summarizing or illustrating key aspects of the narrative.
2. **Does this quote directly support my thesis?** - This question is more focused on the argument or perspective you want to convey in your review. Selecting quotes that support your thesis strengthens your analysis and helps to substantiate your claims about the book.
Ultimately, the reviewer should consider both questions when selecting quotes. They should choose quotes that not only provide context or plot information but also align with and bolster their critical argument or thesis about the book.