Scientists discovered two new planets: planet X and planet Y. They have identical volumes, but the mass of planet X is two times greater than the mass of planet Y. If two identical space probes land on each planet, which of the following will be true?(1 point)

Responses

The weight of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet Y.
The weight of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet Y.

The mass of the space probe on planet Y will be greater than the mass of the space probe on planet X.
The mass of the space probe on planet Y will be greater than the mass of the space probe on planet X.

The weight of the space probe on planet Y will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet X.
The weight of the space probe on planet Y will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet X.

The mass of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the mass of the space probe on planet Y.
The mass of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the mass of the space probe on planet Y.

1 answer

To determine the correct statements regarding the space probes on planets X and Y, let's analyze the situation based on gravitational effects.

  1. Weight: The weight of an object is given by the formula \( W = m \cdot g \), where \( m \) is the mass of the object and \( g \) is the gravitational acceleration on the surface of the planet. Since the two planets have identical volumes but different masses, the gravitational acceleration will differ between them.

    • Let the mass of planet Y be \( m \) and the mass of planet X be \( 2m \).
    • The gravitational attraction (and thus the surface gravity, \( g \)) is proportional to the mass of the planet and inversely proportional to the square of its radius. Since both planets have the same volume, we can infer that:
      • Planet X, being more massive, will have a greater surface gravity \( g_X \) than planet Y \( g_Y \). Thus, \( g_X > g_Y \).
    • As a result, the weight of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet Y because \( W_X = m_{probe} \cdot g_X > W_Y = m_{probe} \cdot g_Y \).
  2. Mass: The mass of the space probes does not change based on the gravitational field of the planets they land on. The mass of space probes is a property of the probes themselves and remains constant regardless of the planet. Therefore:

    • The mass of the space probes on planet X is equal to the mass of the space probes on planet Y.

Now, we can analyze the responses:

  • The weight of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet Y. (True)
  • The mass of the space probe on planet Y will be greater than the mass of the space probe on planet X. (False)
  • The weight of the space probe on planet Y will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet X. (False)
  • The mass of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the mass of the space probe on planet Y. (False)

The correct response is: The weight of the space probe on planet X will be greater than the weight of the space probe on planet Y.