The correct response to the student's claim is: No, dominant traits in general tend to be less common in the population and continue to persist only because they are dominant over more common recessive alleles.
This is because a dominant trait can be present in fewer individuals in a population while still expressing itself whenever at least one dominant allele is present. Dominance does not necessarily correlate with frequency; a recessive trait can be more common if it is carried by many individuals in a heterozygous form (where they have one copy of the dominant allele and one of the recessive allele). Furthermore, some dominant traits may arise from mutations and not be widely prevalent. Therefore, the statement that dominant traits are always the most common is incorrect.