When should a writer include counterclaims in the body of the essay and refute them point by point?

Question

A. When the scenarios are equally persuasive to the writer's claims. B. When the counterclaims are less persuasive than the writer's claims. C. When the counterclaims are well accepted by the reader. D. When the counterclaims are familiar to the reader.

Answer 1

A writer should include counterclaims in the body of the essay and refute them point by point:

A. When the scenarios are equally persuasive to the writer's claims.

Including counterclaims can strengthen the writer's argument by demonstrating an understanding of differing viewpoints and effectively addressing those perspectives. However, it's particularly important to engage with counterclaims that are compelling or strong, as it shows that the writer acknowledges and can refute opposing arguments, thus reinforcing their own position.