Refer to your Expeditions in Reading book for a complete version of these texts.

Question

How are the ideas presented in “Make Your Own Microscope” and “Stick to Real Microscopes” different?

Responses

“Make Your Own Microscope” lists portability as a benefit of smartphone microscopes, but “Stick to Real Microscopes” states that portability is not important.
“Make Your Own Microscope” lists portability as a benefit of smartphone microscopes, but “Stick to Real Microscopes” states that portability is not important.

The first text states that both smartphone and real microscopes have video capabilities, but the second text claims only real microscopes take video.
The first text states that both smartphone and real microscopes have video capabilities, but the second text claims only real microscopes take video.

The first text focuses on the positive aspects of turning a smartphone into a microscope, but the second text focuses on how smartphone microscopes are inferior to real microscopes.
The first text focuses on the positive aspects of turning a smartphone into a microscope, but the second text focuses on how smartphone microscopes are inferior to real microscopes.

“Make Your Own Microscope” addresses opposing opinions about smartphone microscopes, but “Stick to Real Microscopes” presents only one side.

Answer 1

The differences in the ideas presented in “Make Your Own Microscope” and “Stick to Real Microscopes” can be summarized as follows:

• Focus on Benefits vs. Limitations:

  • “Make Your Own Microscope” emphasizes the positive aspects of using a smartphone as a microscope, such as portability and accessibility for everyday users.
  • In contrast, “Stick to Real Microscopes” focuses on the limitations and inferiority of smartphone microscopes compared to traditional, real microscopes, highlighting the drawbacks and reasons why real microscopes are preferable.

• Presentation of Perspectives:

  • “Make Your Own Microscope” may acknowledge some counterarguments about smartphone microscopes, giving a more balanced view.
  • “Stick to Real Microscopes,” on the other hand, tends to present a singular perspective, reinforcing the belief that only traditional microscopes are the appropriate choice.

Based on this analysis, the most accurate response would be:

The first text focuses on the positive aspects of turning a smartphone into a microscope, but the second text focuses on how smartphone microscopes are inferior to real microscopes.