Question

How does Jordan's use of historical context strengthen her constitutional argument?

Using contemporary political rhetoric
By quoting Framers' original constitutional intentions
Through emotional personal anecdotes
Presenting modern legal interpretations

Answer 1

Jordan's use of historical context strengthens her constitutional argument primarily by quoting Framers' original constitutional intentions. By referencing the original meanings and intentions behind the Constitution, she grounds her argument in the foundational principles that guided the formation of American law. This approach not only lends credibility to her claims but also aligns her reasoning with the original goals of the Constitution, helping to reinforce her position in a manner that resonates with constitutional originalism.

While contemporary political rhetoric and modern legal interpretations can also be effective, they might lack the same depth of foundation provided by historical context. Emotional personal anecdotes can be powerful for persuasion but may not carry the same weight in a legal argument as references to the intentions of the Framers. Therefore, using historical context through the Framers' original intentions remains a central strength in crafting a compelling constitutional argument.