(Messenger, Stephen. “Turtle Cut Free From 6-Pack Rings Is Unstoppable 20 Years Later.” The Dodo, 26 May 2015,) Use this photo to answer the following 3 part question. Part One: Text Structure What type of text structure (e.g., cause and effect, problem and solution, etc.) would best explain the issue shown in this photo? Explain why this structure is the most effective choice. Part 2: Rhetoric Which type of rhetorical appeal (ethos, pathos, or logos) could this photo be used for? Explain how the photo supports this type of rhetoric and why it might be persuasive. Part 3: Persuasive Techniques When persuading an audience about this issue, which approach do you think would be more effective: showing this photo or describing the issue with vivid imagery? Justify your choice by explaining how it impacts the audience emotionally, logically, or through credibility. You should write 3-5 Sentences for each part.(6 points)

1 answer

Part One: Text Structure

The best text structure to explain the issue shown in the photo is problem and solution. The image likely illustrates the consequences of plastic pollution, specifically the impact of six-pack rings on wildlife such as turtles, which is a significant environmental problem. This structure effectively highlights the initial problem of marine animals being harmed by plastic waste while also emphasizing potential solutions, such as advocating for the use of biodegradable materials or promoting recycling initiatives. By framing the narrative this way, the audience can grasp the urgency of the issue and see a pathway towards making a positive change.

Part Two: Rhetoric

The photo would primarily appeal through pathos, effective in evoking an emotional response from the audience. The image of the turtle, possibly showing its struggles or resilience, elicits feelings of empathy and concern for animal welfare. This emotional appeal is persuasive as it humanizes the plight of wildlife affected by plastic pollution, prompting the audience to reflect on the ethical implications of their consumption habits. By tapping into the viewers' emotions, the photo can inspire action and foster a deeper connection to environmental issues.

Part Three: Persuasive Techniques

Showing the photo would likely be more effective than describing the issue with vivid imagery. Visuals can have an immediate and powerful impact by allowing the audience to see the direct consequences of plastic pollution on a specific animal, making the problem more tangible and relatable. The emotional engagement from a compelling image can prompt quicker reactions and a stronger call to action compared to mere words, which might not generate the same level of urgency. Therefore, the photo leverages emotional resonance and immediacy, creating a memorable and persuasive case for addressing environmental concerns.