Counterclaim: Banning plastic water bottles removes a healthy option for a beverage.

Question

Which claim might someone argue and include the counterclaim?

A. Plastic bottles could contain harmful chemicals.
B. Plastic water bottles should be banned. They cause enormous waste and environmental issues.
C. Plastic water bottles are one of the leading contributors to landfill waste.
D. Plastic water bottles cost a lot of money to produce and there are many cheaper options.

Answer 1

B. Plastic water bottles should be banned. They cause enormous waste and environmental issues.

In this case, the counterclaim that banning plastic water bottles removes a healthy option for a beverage fits well. The argument can proceed by acknowledging the environmental issues posed by plastic waste while addressing the concern that eliminating plastic water bottles could limit access to a healthy hydration option.