Question

In 3-5 sentences, explain one example of valid reasoning and explain how that example strengthens the overall argument. Biodegradable plastic bags, not so biodegradable

Answer 1

One example of valid reasoning in the argument that biodegradable plastic bags are not truly biodegradable is the observation that many of these bags only break down under specific conditions—like industrial composting facilities—which are not widely available. This reasoning strengthens the overall argument by highlighting the disconnect between the promise of biodegradability and the actual conditions required for it to occur. By showing that many biodegradable bags may simply end up in landfills where they do not decompose, the argument underscores the potential environmental harm and misleads consumers who believe they are making a more eco-friendly choice.