Question
Subject: dogs
Narrowed Subject: the benefits of service dogs to the mentally ill
Thesis Statement: My service dog, Bobo, changed my life by making me more independent, adventurous, and confident.
Which of these are true of the previous thesis statement? Check all that apply.
The thesis statement indicates that part of the essay will talk about how the service dog helped the writer to be more adventurous.
The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss the writer's mental illness.
The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss how Bobo, the service dog, changed the writer's life in three specific ways.
The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.
Subject: crime
Narrowed Subject: domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia
Thesis Statement: Domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia, is frightening and rampant.
Which of these are true of the previous thesis statement? Check all that apply.
The thesis statement indicates that the essay will describe the reasons for rampant domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia.
The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.
The thesis statement suggests that domestic violence is a bigger problem in Atlanta, Georgia, than in other big cities.
The thesis statement makes a general claim without providing the reader with any particular direction.
Narrowed Subject: the benefits of service dogs to the mentally ill
Thesis Statement: My service dog, Bobo, changed my life by making me more independent, adventurous, and confident.
Which of these are true of the previous thesis statement? Check all that apply.
The thesis statement indicates that part of the essay will talk about how the service dog helped the writer to be more adventurous.
The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss the writer's mental illness.
The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss how Bobo, the service dog, changed the writer's life in three specific ways.
The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.
Subject: crime
Narrowed Subject: domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia
Thesis Statement: Domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia, is frightening and rampant.
Which of these are true of the previous thesis statement? Check all that apply.
The thesis statement indicates that the essay will describe the reasons for rampant domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia.
The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.
The thesis statement suggests that domestic violence is a bigger problem in Atlanta, Georgia, than in other big cities.
The thesis statement makes a general claim without providing the reader with any particular direction.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
### For the thesis statement about service dogs:
1. **The thesis statement indicates that part of the essay will talk about how the service dog helped the writer to be more adventurous.**
- **True:** The thesis explicitly mentions that the service dog made the writer "more adventurous."
2. **The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss the writer's mental illness.**
- **False:** While the narrowed subject relates to the mentally ill, the thesis statement does not specifically mention the writer's mental illness.
3. **The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss how Bobo, the service dog, changed the writer's life in three specific ways.**
- **True:** The thesis states that Bobo changed the writer's life in three specific ways: more independent, adventurous, and confident.
4. **The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.**
- **False:** The thesis is clear and provides specific ways in which Bobo impacted the writer's life.
---
### For the thesis statement about domestic violence:
1. **The thesis statement indicates that the essay will describe the reasons for rampant domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia.**
- **False:** The thesis does not specify reasons; it only states that domestic violence is frightening and rampant.
2. **The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.**
- **True:** While it communicates a strong assertion, it lacks details or specificity about what will be discussed.
3. **The thesis statement suggests that domestic violence is a bigger problem in Atlanta, Georgia, than in other big cities.**
- **False:** The thesis does not make comparisons with other cities; it only focuses on Atlanta.
4. **The thesis statement makes a general claim without providing the reader with any particular direction.**
- **True:** The thesis presents a general claim but lacks direction on what aspects of domestic violence will be addressed.
1. **The thesis statement indicates that part of the essay will talk about how the service dog helped the writer to be more adventurous.**
- **True:** The thesis explicitly mentions that the service dog made the writer "more adventurous."
2. **The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss the writer's mental illness.**
- **False:** While the narrowed subject relates to the mentally ill, the thesis statement does not specifically mention the writer's mental illness.
3. **The thesis statement suggests that the essay will discuss how Bobo, the service dog, changed the writer's life in three specific ways.**
- **True:** The thesis states that Bobo changed the writer's life in three specific ways: more independent, adventurous, and confident.
4. **The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.**
- **False:** The thesis is clear and provides specific ways in which Bobo impacted the writer's life.
---
### For the thesis statement about domestic violence:
1. **The thesis statement indicates that the essay will describe the reasons for rampant domestic violence in Atlanta, Georgia.**
- **False:** The thesis does not specify reasons; it only states that domestic violence is frightening and rampant.
2. **The thesis statement is not clear or specific enough for a good essay.**
- **True:** While it communicates a strong assertion, it lacks details or specificity about what will be discussed.
3. **The thesis statement suggests that domestic violence is a bigger problem in Atlanta, Georgia, than in other big cities.**
- **False:** The thesis does not make comparisons with other cities; it only focuses on Atlanta.
4. **The thesis statement makes a general claim without providing the reader with any particular direction.**
- **True:** The thesis presents a general claim but lacks direction on what aspects of domestic violence will be addressed.