The correct statement that explains why the student's claim is incorrect is:
The reaction produced a gas that escaped the beaker.
This indicates that some of the mass was lost to the environment in the form of gas, which aligns with the principle of conservation of mass. During a chemical reaction or mixing of substances, if a gas is released and escapes, the total mass measured may appear to be less, but matter is still conserved overall; it has just taken a different form (in this case, gas).