Asked by Jucewrld the party never ends
Portfolio Debate Scenario: Imagine you are trying to convince Ms. Warner not to give you an extra portfolio assignment. Answer the following 2 part question: Part 1: Which rhetorical strategy (ethos, pathos, or logos) would be the most effective for your argument? Explain why this strategy would work best with Ms. Warner. Part 2: Write your argument. Use the rhetorical strategy you chose. Make your case as persuasive as possible! (5 points)
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
### Part 1: Rhetorical Strategy
For this scenario, the most effective rhetorical strategy would be **pathos**. This strategy focuses on appealing to emotions, which can be particularly persuasive when addressing a person's discretion, such as a teacher's decision about assigning additional work. Ms. Warner may be influenced by a sense of empathy or understanding towards her students, and tapping into those emotions can help convey the challenges that an extra assignment would pose. By sharing personal experiences, expressing commitment to learning, and highlighting the emotional toll of an increased workload, I can connect with her on a human level, potentially swaying her decision against the additional assignment.
### Part 2: Argument
Dear Ms. Warner,
I hope this message finds you well. I wanted to take a moment to discuss the proposed extra portfolio assignment and share my thoughts from a personal perspective.
As you know, this semester has been particularly demanding, not only due to the assignments in your class but also because of the myriad other responsibilities we juggle daily. Between studying for exams, participating in extracurricular activities, and managing part-time jobs, many of us are stretched to our limits. The thought of an additional portfolio assignment looms over us like a dark cloud, creating unnecessary stress and anxiety.
I truly value the education and guidance you provide. It’s evident that you care deeply about our learning and growth, and for that, I am grateful. However, it’s important to consider the emotional impact this extra assignment may have on students. Adding more pressure might detract from the quality of work we are able to produce and diminishes our ability to truly engage with the content. Instead of fostering creativity and learning, it can lead to burnout, detracting from our enthusiasm for the subject.
I, like many of my classmates, want to submit work that reflects my best efforts and showcases what I’ve learned in your class. I fear that an additional assignment will hinder my ability to do so and may even lead to feelings of inadequacy or frustration.
I respectfully ask you to reconsider the extra portfolio assignment. Perhaps we can look at ways to deepen our understanding of the material within the framework of the assignments you’ve already set. I am committed to my education and am more than willing to put in the effort required, but I believe managing our workload is essential for our overall well-being and success.
Thank you for considering my perspective, and I hope we can find a path that supports both our learning and our mental health.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
For this scenario, the most effective rhetorical strategy would be **pathos**. This strategy focuses on appealing to emotions, which can be particularly persuasive when addressing a person's discretion, such as a teacher's decision about assigning additional work. Ms. Warner may be influenced by a sense of empathy or understanding towards her students, and tapping into those emotions can help convey the challenges that an extra assignment would pose. By sharing personal experiences, expressing commitment to learning, and highlighting the emotional toll of an increased workload, I can connect with her on a human level, potentially swaying her decision against the additional assignment.
### Part 2: Argument
Dear Ms. Warner,
I hope this message finds you well. I wanted to take a moment to discuss the proposed extra portfolio assignment and share my thoughts from a personal perspective.
As you know, this semester has been particularly demanding, not only due to the assignments in your class but also because of the myriad other responsibilities we juggle daily. Between studying for exams, participating in extracurricular activities, and managing part-time jobs, many of us are stretched to our limits. The thought of an additional portfolio assignment looms over us like a dark cloud, creating unnecessary stress and anxiety.
I truly value the education and guidance you provide. It’s evident that you care deeply about our learning and growth, and for that, I am grateful. However, it’s important to consider the emotional impact this extra assignment may have on students. Adding more pressure might detract from the quality of work we are able to produce and diminishes our ability to truly engage with the content. Instead of fostering creativity and learning, it can lead to burnout, detracting from our enthusiasm for the subject.
I, like many of my classmates, want to submit work that reflects my best efforts and showcases what I’ve learned in your class. I fear that an additional assignment will hinder my ability to do so and may even lead to feelings of inadequacy or frustration.
I respectfully ask you to reconsider the extra portfolio assignment. Perhaps we can look at ways to deepen our understanding of the material within the framework of the assignments you’ve already set. I am committed to my education and am more than willing to put in the effort required, but I believe managing our workload is essential for our overall well-being and success.
Thank you for considering my perspective, and I hope we can find a path that supports both our learning and our mental health.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
There are no human answers yet. A form for humans to post answers is coming very soon!