Short Answer question

“When Andrew Johnson took upon himself the duties of his high office he swore to obey the Constitution and take care that the laws be faithfully executed. That, indeed, is and has always been the chief duty of the President of the United States. The duties of legislation and adjudicating [making a judgment on] the laws of his country fall in no way to his lot. To obey the commands of sovereign power of the nation, and to see that others should obey them, was his whole duty—a duty which he could not escape, and any attempt to do so would be in direct violation of his official oath…”

—Thaddeus Stevens, Closing Remarks in the Impeachment Trial of Andrew Johnson, 1868

In the passage above, why does Thaddeus Stevens feel Andrew Johnson should be impeached?
- What does it mean to be impeached?

- What are some reasons to why he was impeached?

1 answer

Thaddeus Stevens feels Andrew Johnson should be impeached because he believes Johnson has failed to uphold his constitutional duties as President. According to Stevens, Johnson has not faithfully executed the laws and has overstepped his authority, which he views as a direct violation of Johnson's official oath. Stevens argues that the President's primary duty is to obey and enforce the laws of the nation, and any attempt to act outside of that responsibility warrants impeachment.

To be impeached means to be formally charged with misconduct while in office. Impeachment is a constitutional process that allows Congress to remove a president or other federal officials from their positions if they are found guilty of "high crimes and misdemeanors."

Some reasons Andrew Johnson was impeached include:

  1. Violation of the Tenure of Office Act: Johnson attempted to remove Edwin Stanton, the Secretary of War, from his position, which many viewed as a violation of this law meant to restrict the president’s power to remove certain officeholders without the Senate's approval.

  2. Failure to Enforce Reconstruction Laws: Johnson was criticized for not fully supporting the Reconstruction efforts put forth by Congress, which aimed to rebuild and integrate the Southern states after the Civil War.

  3. Abuse of Presidential Power: He was accused of undermining the authority of Congress and exhibiting a lack of respect for the legislative branch, particularly regarding civil rights and the protection of newly freed slaves.

  4. Public Statements: Johnson’s inflammatory speeches and public statements often contradicted the policies of Reconstruction and inflamed tensions, leading to resentment among Republican lawmakers.

These reasons contributed to the belief among Stevens and others in Congress that Johnson's actions warranted impeachment.

Similar Questions
  1. Use the quotation to answer the following question:According to the quotation, why does Stevens believe that Johnson should be
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  2. From Andrew Johnson's Impeachment Trial:“When Andrew Johnson took upon himself the duties of his high office he swore to obey
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  3. 2 of 22 of 2 ItemsFeature From Andrew Johnson's Impeachment Trial: “When Andrew Johnson took upon himself the duties of his
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  4. From Andrew Johnson's Impeachment Trial:“When Andrew Johnson took upon himself the duties of his high office he swore to obey
    1. answers icon 1 answer
more similar questions