Question
What would happen if you reversed the order of paragraphs 3 and 4?
(1 point)
Responses
The focus of the article would shift from old statistics to trends in the industry.
The focus of the article would shift from old statistics to trends in the industry.
The broader implications of an idea would be discussed before the reader understands what the idea is.
The broader implications of an idea would be discussed before the reader understands what the idea is.
The extent of the problem would be lost on readers because they would not receive all the data.
The extent of the problem would be lost on readers because they would not receive all the data.
The importance of the problem would become clearer because the worldwide impact would be centered sooner.
The trend is not limited to the U.S., or even to media. A survey of 500 media companies in nearly 60 countries discovered that men hold 73 percent of management positions. And among Fortune 500 CEOs, women account for 4.8 percent.
There are, of course, high-profile exceptions; Arianna Huffington and Marissa Meyer among them. The ASNE survey shows women among the top three leaders at 63 percent of print organizations. But according to the numbers, these instances do little to mitigate a larger trend.
(1 point)
Responses
The focus of the article would shift from old statistics to trends in the industry.
The focus of the article would shift from old statistics to trends in the industry.
The broader implications of an idea would be discussed before the reader understands what the idea is.
The broader implications of an idea would be discussed before the reader understands what the idea is.
The extent of the problem would be lost on readers because they would not receive all the data.
The extent of the problem would be lost on readers because they would not receive all the data.
The importance of the problem would become clearer because the worldwide impact would be centered sooner.
The trend is not limited to the U.S., or even to media. A survey of 500 media companies in nearly 60 countries discovered that men hold 73 percent of management positions. And among Fortune 500 CEOs, women account for 4.8 percent.
There are, of course, high-profile exceptions; Arianna Huffington and Marissa Meyer among them. The ASNE survey shows women among the top three leaders at 63 percent of print organizations. But according to the numbers, these instances do little to mitigate a larger trend.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
Reversing the order of paragraphs 3 and 4 would likely lead to some significant changes in the clarity and flow of the article. Here's a breakdown of the potential consequences:
1. **Shift in Focus**: The article would start discussing specific examples of high-profile exceptions (from paragraph 4) before establishing the context of the broader trend represented by the statistics (from paragraph 3). This could confuse readers about the significance of the exceptions until they fully grasp the overall trend.
2. **Lack of Context**: Readers might feel bewildered or misled if they first encounter examples of exceptions before understanding the underlying issue represented by the statistics. They may not appreciate the relevance of the exceptions without the prior context of the statistics.
3. **Impact on Argument Structure**: The argument structure could weaken, as readers need a solid grasp of the broader statistics and trends before delving into specific cases. This may lead to a misunderstanding of why the exceptions are noteworthy.
4. **Potential Misinterpretation**: Readers could misinterpret the exceptions as more prevalent or significant than they are, losing sight of the larger trend that indicates a continuing disparity in management positions between genders.
In summary, the reversal would likely lead to confusion and a less effective presentation of the article's argument regarding gender representation in management roles.
1. **Shift in Focus**: The article would start discussing specific examples of high-profile exceptions (from paragraph 4) before establishing the context of the broader trend represented by the statistics (from paragraph 3). This could confuse readers about the significance of the exceptions until they fully grasp the overall trend.
2. **Lack of Context**: Readers might feel bewildered or misled if they first encounter examples of exceptions before understanding the underlying issue represented by the statistics. They may not appreciate the relevance of the exceptions without the prior context of the statistics.
3. **Impact on Argument Structure**: The argument structure could weaken, as readers need a solid grasp of the broader statistics and trends before delving into specific cases. This may lead to a misunderstanding of why the exceptions are noteworthy.
4. **Potential Misinterpretation**: Readers could misinterpret the exceptions as more prevalent or significant than they are, losing sight of the larger trend that indicates a continuing disparity in management positions between genders.
In summary, the reversal would likely lead to confusion and a less effective presentation of the article's argument regarding gender representation in management roles.