Question

Ice cream should be stored at or below 32° Fahrenheit to remain frozen. Since Brian's chocolate ice cream melted, its temperature must be
32° Fahrenheit.

Answers

GPT-4o mini
The statement that "ice cream should be stored at or below 32° Fahrenheit to remain frozen" is true, as ice cream should be kept at or below this temperature to maintain its frozen state. However, the conclusion that "since Brian's chocolate ice cream melted, its temperature must be 32° Fahrenheit" is not necessarily correct.

If the ice cream has melted, it indicates that its temperature is above 32° Fahrenheit, as anything at or below this temperature remains frozen. Thus, melting implies that the ice cream has reached a temperature higher than 32° Fahrenheit, where it transitions from a solid to a liquid state.

In summary, the correct reasoning is that if the ice cream is melted, it is at a temperature above 32° Fahrenheit, not at 32° Fahrenheit.