Question
There were, prior to December 7, 1941, Japanese spies on the island of Oahu. Some were Japanese consular agents and others were persons having no open relations with the Japanese foreign service. These spies collected and, through various channels transmitted, information to the Japanese Empire respecting the military and naval establishments and dispositions on the island.
–Report of the Roberts Commission,
January 23, 1942
Why might a student cite this report in an argumentative essay on Japanese American internment? Check all that apply.
It provides support for the argument that internment was wrong.
It provides one of the reasons Roosevelt decided to issue internment orders.
It reveals that the internment decision was made based partially on misinformation.
It is from a credible source, so the information in the report must be true.
–Report of the Roberts Commission,
January 23, 1942
Why might a student cite this report in an argumentative essay on Japanese American internment? Check all that apply.
It provides support for the argument that internment was wrong.
It provides one of the reasons Roosevelt decided to issue internment orders.
It reveals that the internment decision was made based partially on misinformation.
It is from a credible source, so the information in the report must be true.
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
In considering how a student might cite the report of the Roberts Commission in an argumentative essay on Japanese American internment, the following options would apply:
- **It provides one of the reasons Roosevelt decided to issue internment orders.**
The quote indicates concerns about Japanese spies and espionage, which contributed to the climate of fear and urgency that influenced the decision to intern Japanese Americans.
- **It reveals that the internment decision was made based partially on misinformation.**
The report highlights the presence of spies and the potential for espionage, but it does not provide evidence that Japanese Americans were involved in such activities. This can support the argument that internment was based on exaggerated fears rather than factual evidence.
The options that would not apply are:
- **It provides support for the argument that internment was wrong.**
While the report raises concerns about the actions of Japanese spies, it does not directly argue against the justification for internment.
- **It is from a credible source, so the information in the report must be true.**
While the report is from a credible source, this statement itself does not substantiate the claims regarding internment. Credibility does not guarantee the veracity of all assertions made in the report.
In conclusion, the most relevant citations for supporting an argument about Japanese American internment would be the first and third options.
- **It provides one of the reasons Roosevelt decided to issue internment orders.**
The quote indicates concerns about Japanese spies and espionage, which contributed to the climate of fear and urgency that influenced the decision to intern Japanese Americans.
- **It reveals that the internment decision was made based partially on misinformation.**
The report highlights the presence of spies and the potential for espionage, but it does not provide evidence that Japanese Americans were involved in such activities. This can support the argument that internment was based on exaggerated fears rather than factual evidence.
The options that would not apply are:
- **It provides support for the argument that internment was wrong.**
While the report raises concerns about the actions of Japanese spies, it does not directly argue against the justification for internment.
- **It is from a credible source, so the information in the report must be true.**
While the report is from a credible source, this statement itself does not substantiate the claims regarding internment. Credibility does not guarantee the veracity of all assertions made in the report.
In conclusion, the most relevant citations for supporting an argument about Japanese American internment would be the first and third options.