Question
How do u define a balance section applying recommendations id IS 456 for ‘working stress method of design & limit stress method of design
Answers
Answered by
GPT-4o mini
In the context of structural design according to IS 456:2000, the balance section concept applies differently to the Working Stress Method (WSM) and the Limit State Method (LSM). Below, I'll outline how a balance section can be defined in both methods, keeping in mind the guidelines of IS 456.
### 1. Working Stress Method (WSM)
**Definition of a Balance Section:**
In the Working Stress Method, a balance section is defined primarily to ensure that the stresses in concrete and steel remain within permissible limits under the service loads. The section is considered balanced when the steel reinforcement reaches its yield strength while the concrete remains uncracked and within its linear elastic range.
**Design Principles:**
- **Flexural Design:** For a balance section in flexural design, the moment of resistance (Mu) is calculated using the formula that relates the stress in steel (Fe) to the working stress in concrete (fc). The design needs to ensure that:
\[
Mu = \sigma \cdot Z
\]
Where \( \sigma \) is the permissible stress in steel, and \( Z \) is the section modulus.
- **Load Safety:** Ensure that the loads do not exceed the allowable working stresses for both concrete and steel.
**Key Factors:**
- **Permissible Stresses:** Stress limits for concrete (typically 0.6 to 0.8 of the characteristic strength) and steel (up to yield strength).
- **Factor of Safety:** A factor of safety is applied to determine the permissible stresses. For instance, the factor of safety for concrete is generally taken as 3 and for steel as 1.5.
### 2. Limit State Method (LSM)
**Definition of a Balance Section:**
In the Limit State Method, a balance section is determined based on the ultimate load conditions, ensuring that both concrete and steel reach their respective failure criteria. The balance section is defined in relation to the force equilibrium of ultimate loads.
**Design Principles:**
- **Ultimate Limit State Design:** For a balance section, the design needs to consider both the yielding of steel and the crushing of concrete as part of the equilibrium of moments:
\[
M_u = M_{crushing} + M_{yielding}
\]
Where \( M_u \) is the ultimate moment, \( M_{crushing} \) is the moment at which concrete fails by crushing, and \( M_{yielding} \) is the moment when steel reaches its yield point.
- **Partial Safety Factors:** IS 456 provides partial safety factors for loads and material strengths. For example, a factor of 1.5 is typically used for structural loads and 1.5 for the materials' strength.
**Key Factors:**
- **Limit States:** The design should consider limit states of both serviceability and ultimate strength, ensuring that the structure behaves adequately under the prescribed loads.
- **Compatibility of Deformations:** A balanced design should also ensure that the deflections, cracks, and other serviceability criteria are satisfied, thereby keeping the structure within serviceable limits under anticipated loads.
### Conclusion
In summary, a balance section is defined differently in WSM and LSM approaches based on the nature of stress states being considered (working vs. limit state). In WSM, emphasis is on maintaining stresses within permissible limits, while in LSM, the design is based on achieving a balance of ultimate moments and forces at failure. IS 456 offers guidelines and parameters to ensure safety, serviceability, and structural integrity in both methods.
### 1. Working Stress Method (WSM)
**Definition of a Balance Section:**
In the Working Stress Method, a balance section is defined primarily to ensure that the stresses in concrete and steel remain within permissible limits under the service loads. The section is considered balanced when the steel reinforcement reaches its yield strength while the concrete remains uncracked and within its linear elastic range.
**Design Principles:**
- **Flexural Design:** For a balance section in flexural design, the moment of resistance (Mu) is calculated using the formula that relates the stress in steel (Fe) to the working stress in concrete (fc). The design needs to ensure that:
\[
Mu = \sigma \cdot Z
\]
Where \( \sigma \) is the permissible stress in steel, and \( Z \) is the section modulus.
- **Load Safety:** Ensure that the loads do not exceed the allowable working stresses for both concrete and steel.
**Key Factors:**
- **Permissible Stresses:** Stress limits for concrete (typically 0.6 to 0.8 of the characteristic strength) and steel (up to yield strength).
- **Factor of Safety:** A factor of safety is applied to determine the permissible stresses. For instance, the factor of safety for concrete is generally taken as 3 and for steel as 1.5.
### 2. Limit State Method (LSM)
**Definition of a Balance Section:**
In the Limit State Method, a balance section is determined based on the ultimate load conditions, ensuring that both concrete and steel reach their respective failure criteria. The balance section is defined in relation to the force equilibrium of ultimate loads.
**Design Principles:**
- **Ultimate Limit State Design:** For a balance section, the design needs to consider both the yielding of steel and the crushing of concrete as part of the equilibrium of moments:
\[
M_u = M_{crushing} + M_{yielding}
\]
Where \( M_u \) is the ultimate moment, \( M_{crushing} \) is the moment at which concrete fails by crushing, and \( M_{yielding} \) is the moment when steel reaches its yield point.
- **Partial Safety Factors:** IS 456 provides partial safety factors for loads and material strengths. For example, a factor of 1.5 is typically used for structural loads and 1.5 for the materials' strength.
**Key Factors:**
- **Limit States:** The design should consider limit states of both serviceability and ultimate strength, ensuring that the structure behaves adequately under the prescribed loads.
- **Compatibility of Deformations:** A balanced design should also ensure that the deflections, cracks, and other serviceability criteria are satisfied, thereby keeping the structure within serviceable limits under anticipated loads.
### Conclusion
In summary, a balance section is defined differently in WSM and LSM approaches based on the nature of stress states being considered (working vs. limit state). In WSM, emphasis is on maintaining stresses within permissible limits, while in LSM, the design is based on achieving a balance of ultimate moments and forces at failure. IS 456 offers guidelines and parameters to ensure safety, serviceability, and structural integrity in both methods.
There are no human answers yet. A form for humans to post answers is coming very soon!