Many people agree with zero-tolerance policies in schools. However, some people disagree with these policies. What is the MOST logical argument against having a zero-tolerance policy?

Question

(1 point)
Responses

Sometimes students should automatically be suspended if they make a bad choice.

Sometimes students should automatically be suspended if they make a bad choice.

Sometimes students deserve to be bullied or harassed by other classmates.

Sometimes students deserve to be bullied or harassed by other classmates.

Some students will go unpunished because they are not caught by a teacher.

Some students will go unpunished because they are not caught by a teacher.

Some students will be punished because they make an error that meant no harm.

Some students will be punished because they make an error that meant no harm.

Answer 1

The MOST logical argument against having a zero-tolerance policy is:

Some students will be punished because they make an error that meant no harm.

This argument highlights the concern that zero-tolerance policies can lead to disproportionate consequences for minor mistakes or unintentional actions, rather than taking into account the context or intent behind a student's behavior.