In his assertion that "a work of literature must provide more than factual accuracy or vivid physical reality... it must tell us more than we already know," E. M. Forster emphasizes the transformative power of literature beyond mere description. I wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment. Literature should engage readers on a deeper level, challenging their perceptions and fostering new understandings of the human experience. This idea is exemplified in two literary classics: F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby and George Orwell’s 1984. Both novels, while rooted in their respective realities, transcend mere factual representation to explore profound truths about identity, society, and the human condition.
In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald employs a richly woven narrative that captures the materialism and moral decay of the Jazz Age. The plot centers around the enigmatic Jay Gatsby, whose unyielding pursuit of the American Dream leads to his tragic downfall. While the novel accurately depicts the opulence of the 1920s through its vivid settings—like the extravagant parties at Gatsby's mansion—its true power lies in its exploration of more complex themes, such as the illusion of the American Dream and the inherent emptiness of wealth. This theme is articulated through the characterization of Gatsby himself; he is a self-made man, yet his lavish lifestyle and devotion to Daisy Buchanan reveal a deep-seated emptiness—he is unable to grasp the very thing he longs for, embodying the disillusionment that often accompanies unfulfilled aspirations.
Fitzgerald’s use of symbolism, particularly the green light at the end of Daisy's dock, is another formal feature that transcends the factual realm. The green light represents Gatsby’s unattainable dreams, serving as a poignant reminder of the gap between illusion and reality. This layered meaning invites readers to reflect on their own desires and the societal structures that shape them, thus teaching us more about the nature of aspiration, love, and loss than we could glean from the factual recounting of the Roaring Twenties.
Similarly, in George Orwell’s 1984, the narrative offers a chilling glimpse into a totalitarian society that prioritizes control and conformity over individual freedom. The stark reality of pervasive surveillance and oppressive regime reflects factual elements of dictatorship; however, it is the exploration of themes such as power, language, and the malleability of truth that render the work profoundly impactful. The characterization of Winston Smith, who battles against the overwhelming force of Big Brother, serves to illustrate the struggle for personal autonomy within a society that seeks to obliterate it.
Orwell’s innovative use of language—most notably Newspeak, a language designed to limit thought—demonstrates how literature can explore the implications of language on freedom and identity. The phrase, "War is Peace. Freedom is Slavery. Ignorance is Strength," encapsulates the paradoxes inherent in totalitarian ideology, forcing readers to confront uncomfortable truths about power dynamics and the nature of reality. This notion extends beyond the narrative, urging readers to reflect on the impact of language in their own lives. In doing so, 1984 illustrates Forster’s argument that literature must engage readers on a deeper, more analytical level, compelling them to question accepted truths and confront difficult societal realities.
In conclusion, literature should do more than depict factual realities; it should engage and challenge readers’ understanding of the human experience. Both The Great Gatsby and 1984 serve as powerful examples of how novels can transcend mere representation to illuminate deeper truths about identity, society, and aspiration. Through their exploration of themes, characterization, and symbolic elements, these works illustrate that literature has the potential to reveal insights that resonate far beyond their pages, fulfilling Forster’s call for a deeper engagement with the world of ideas and experiences. Ultimately, great literature invites us to reflect, question, and grow, reinforcing the profound impact it can have on our understanding of life.
1 answer