The most accurate hypothesis for the drastic change in the peppered moth population is:
The light colored moths were easily seen and eaten by predatory birds, but the darker moths avoided being eaten.
This explanation aligns with the concept of natural selection. As the birch trees became darker due to soot from industrial pollution, the light-colored moths became more visible to predators, while the dark-colored moths had better camouflage and were therefore less likely to be eaten. This resulted in a higher survival rate for the darker moths, leading to an increase in their population at the expense of the lighter moths.