In an experiment to determine whether there is a systematic difference between the weights obtained with two different scales, 10 rock specimens were weighed, in grams, on each scale. The following data were obtained:

Question

In an experiment to determine whether there is a systematic difference between the weights obtained with two different scales,  10 rock specimens were weighed, in grams, on each scale. The following data were obtained:
Specimen 1 : weight on scale 1: 12.14 , weight on scale 2: 12/75
Specimen 2: weight on scale 1: 15.51, weight on scale 2: 17.29
specimen 3: 9.83 / 9.42
specimen 4: 12.39/11.33
specimen 5: 27.64/23.87
specimen 6: 10.90/9.36
specimen 7: 15.88/13.78
specimen 8: 6.98/6.88
specimen 9: 13.49/13.55
specimen 10: 21.30/20.10

Let uv1 represent the mean weight on scale 1 and uvd = uv1 - uv2.
Can you conclude that the the mean weight on Scale 1 is greater than the mean weight on Scale 2? Use the a = 0.10 level.

Hv0 : [?]
Hv1 : [?]

This is a [left/right or two tailed?] test

GPT-4o mini · Answer

To determine whether the mean weight on Scale 1 is greater than the mean weight on Scale 2, we can set up the null and alternative hypotheses as follows:

Null Hypothesis (H0): $μ_{1} \leq μ_{2}$ (the mean weight on Scale 1 is less than or equal to the mean weight on Scale 2).

Alternative Hypothesis (H1): $μ_{1} > μ_{2}$ (the mean weight on Scale 1 is greater than the mean weight on Scale 2).

This is a right-tailed test since we are only interested in testing whether the mean weight on Scale 1 is greater than that on Scale 2.

Next Steps

To carry out the hypothesis test, we calculate the sample means and standard deviations of the weights for both scales, followed by calculating the test statistic, and finally determining if we can reject $H_{0}$ using the significance level $α = 0.10$ .

Let's first clean up the data:

Scale 1 weights: 12.14, 15.51, 9.83, 12.39, 27.64, 10.90, 15.88, 6.98, 13.49, 21.30
Scale 2 weights: 12.75, 17.29, 9.42, 11.33, 23.87, 9.36, 13.78, 6.88, 13.55, 20.10

Calculation of Means

Calculate the mean for Scale 1: ${Mean}_{1} = \frac{12.14 + 15.51 + 9.83 + 12.39 + 27.64 + 10.90 + 15.88 + 6.98 + 13.49 + 21.30}{10}$
Calculate the mean for Scale 2: ${Mean}_{2} = \frac{12.75 + 17.29 + 9.42 + 11.33 + 23.87 + 9.36 + 13.78 + 6.88 + 13.55 + 20.10}{10}$

Calculation of the Test Statistic

We can use a t-test for the difference of means, calculated as: \[ t = \frac{\bar{X}1 - \bar{X}2}{s{\text{diff}}} \] where $ s{\text{diff}} $ is the standard error of the difference in means.

Conclusion

After performing the calculations, you will compare the test statistic to the critical t-value from the t-distribution (with 9 degrees of freedom for 10 samples) at the $α = 0.10$ level (right-tailed). If the calculated $t$ is greater than the critical value, you reject the null hypothesis in favor of the alternative hypothesis.

You may also want to compute the p-value for the test statistic to further support your conclusion.

Would you like me to perform these calculations?

Answer

(b) Compute the p-value. Round the answer to at least four decimal places.

GPT-4o mini · Answer

Let's perform the calculations step by step to compute the means, variances, test statistic, and finally the p-value.

Step 1: Calculate the Means

Weights for Scale 1: $12.14, 15.51, 9.83, 12.39, 27.64, 10.90, 15.88, 6.98, 13.49, 21.30$ ${Mean}_{1} = \frac{12.14 + 15.51 + 9.83 + 12.39 + 27.64 + 10.90 + 15.88 + 6.98 + 13.49 + 21.30}{10} = \frac{12.14 + 15.51 + 9.83 + 12.39 + 27.64 + 10.90 + 15.88 + 6.98 + 13.49 + 21.30}{10}$ ${Mean}_{1} = \frac{12.14 + 15.51 + 9.83 + 12.39 + 27.64 + 10.90 + 15.88 + 6.98 + 13.49 + 21.30}{10} = 14.509$
Weights for Scale 2: $12.75, 17.29, 9.42, 11.33, 23.87, 9.36, 13.78, 6.88, 13.55, 20.10$ ${Mean}_{2} = \frac{12.75 + 17.29 + 9.42 + 11.33 + 23.87 + 9.36 + 13.78 + 6.88 + 13.55 + 20.10}{10} = \frac{12.75 + 17.29 + 9.42 + 11.33 + 23.87 + 9.36 + 13.78 + 6.88 + 13.55 + 20.10}{10}$ ${Mean}_{2} = \frac{12.75 + 17.29 + 9.42 + 11.33 + 23.87 + 9.36 + 13.78 + 6.88 + 13.55 + 20.10}{10} = 14.646$

Step 2: Calculate the Standard Deviations

Next, we will calculate the standard deviation for both samples.

Scale 1: $s_{1} = \sqrt{\frac{\sum (x_{1} - \bar{x_{1}})^{2}}{n_{1} - 1}}$ $s_{1} = \sqrt{\frac{(12.14 - 14.509)^{2} + (15.51 - 14.509)^{2} + (9.83 - 14.509)^{2} + (12.39 - 14.509)^{2} + (27.64 - 14.509)^{2} + (10.90 - 14.509)^{2} + (15.88 - 14.509)^{2} + (6.98 - 14.509)^{2} + (13.49 - 14.509)^{2} + (21.30 - 14.509)^{2}}{10 - 1}} \approx 5.876$
Scale 2: $s_{2} = \sqrt{\frac{\sum (x_{2} - \bar{x_{2}})^{2}}{n_{2} - 1}}$ $s_{2} \approx 4.838$

Step 3: Calculate the Test Statistic $t$

The formula for the t-test statistic is: $t = \frac{{\bar{X}}_{1} - {\bar{X}}_{2}}{\sqrt{\frac{s_{1}^{2}}{n_{1}} + \frac{s_{2}^{2}}{n_{2}}}}$ Substituting in:

${\bar{X}}_{1} = 14.509$
${\bar{X}}_{2} = 14.646$
$s_{1} \approx 5.876$
$s_{2} \approx 4.838$
$n_{1} = n_{2} = 10$

$t = \frac{14.509 - 14.646}{\sqrt{\frac{({5.876}^{2})}{10} + \frac{({4.838}^{2})}{10}}}$

Calculating $t$ : $= \frac{- 0.137}{\sqrt{\frac{34.527}{10} + \frac{23.358}{10}}}$ $= \frac{- 0.137}{\sqrt{3.4527 + 2.3358}} = \frac{- 0.137}{\sqrt{5.7885}} \approx \frac{- 0.137}{2.404} \approx - 0.0570 (approx)$

Step 4: Calculate the p-value

Now, with $t \approx - 0.057$ and $d f = n_{1} + n_{2} - 2 = 10 + 10 - 2 = 18$ : Using t-distribution tables or software, we can find the p-value corresponding to a t-statistic of $- 0.057$ in a right-tailed test.

Since the test is one-tailed, we can find the probability that a t random variable (with 18 degrees of freedom) is greater than $- 0.057$ : $p-value = P (T > - 0.057)$

Using statistical calculator or software (like R or Python) to find this, we would find that the p-value approaches 0.5 because for a t-statistic so close to zero and being symmetrical, half the area under the distribution lies above $- 0.057$ .

After performing this calculation, you'll find: $p-value \approx 0.4761 (rounded to four decimal places)$

Thus, the computed p-value is approximately 0.4761.