A government of our own is our natural right: And when a man seriously reflects on the precariousness of human affairs, he will become convinced, that it is infinitely wiser and safer, to form a constitution of our own in a cool deliberate manner, while we have it in our power, than to trust such an interesting event to time and chance.

— Thomas Paine, Common Sense

What effect do you think these words had on the American colonists?

1 answer

Thomas Paine's words in "Common Sense" had a profound effect on American colonists during the time leading up to the American Revolution. Here are several key impacts:

  1. Encouragement of Independence: Paine's assertion that forming their own government was a "natural right" resonated with many colonists who felt oppressed under British rule. His argument encouraged them to consider independence not just as a possibility, but as an inherent right and necessity.

  2. Rational Justification: By urging readers to reflect on the "precariousness of human affairs" and advocating for a rational and deliberate approach to governance, Paine provided a philosophical foundation for rebellion. This helped intellectualize the independence movement, making it more than just an emotional response to British tyranny.

  3. Mobilization of Public Sentiment: "Common Sense" reached a wide audience, thanks to its accessible language and straightforward arguments. It galvanized public sentiment and mobilized ordinary colonists, many of whom were previously ambivalent about independence.

  4. Challenge to Monarchical Rule: Paine's critique of monarchy and hereditary succession challenged existing political norms and structures. This encouraged colonists to rethink their allegiance to the British crown and to envision a new political identity based on democratic principles.

  5. Catalyst for Action: The urgency of Paine's message—advocating for immediate action rather than waiting for circumstances to dictate their fate—spurred many colonists to support the revolutionary cause. It helped transform passive dissatisfaction into active involvement in the fight for independence.

In summary, Paine's writings played a crucial role in shaping colonial attitudes towards independence, fostering a sense of agency and urgency that contributed significantly to the revolutionary movement.