What elements should be included in a paragraph that evaluates a writer’s argument? Select three options.

Question

a brief biography of the writer
a summary of the writer's claim
an analysis of the writer's concluding statements
an analysis of the writer's reasons and evidence
a response to the writer's position saying if it is right or wrong

Answer 1

To effectively evaluate a writer’s argument, the following three elements should be included:

1. A summary of the writer's claim - This provides context and helps the reader understand the main argument being addressed.

2. An analysis of the writer's reasons and evidence - This involves examining the support provided for the claim, assessing its validity and relevance.

3. A response to the writer's position saying if it is right or wrong - This offers a judgment on the effectiveness of the argument and can include whether the claim is justified based on the analysis.

These elements work together to create a comprehensive evaluation of the writer's argument.