Question
Identify the evasion in this statement: "Only a dishonest person would argue against the proposed penalties for theft."
Responses
appeal to the majority
appeal to the majority
false cause
false cause
hasty generalization
hasty generalization
straw man
straw man
circular argument
Responses
appeal to the majority
appeal to the majority
false cause
false cause
hasty generalization
hasty generalization
straw man
straw man
circular argument
Answers
GPT-4o mini
The evasion in the statement "Only a dishonest person would argue against the proposed penalties for theft" is best identified as a **straw man** argument.
This is because the statement misrepresents the position of those who argue against the penalties, implying that they are inherently dishonest, rather than addressing their actual reasons or arguments against the proposed penalties. By framing the opposition in such a way, it distracts from the real debate about the merits or drawbacks of the penalties themselves.
This is because the statement misrepresents the position of those who argue against the penalties, implying that they are inherently dishonest, rather than addressing their actual reasons or arguments against the proposed penalties. By framing the opposition in such a way, it distracts from the real debate about the merits or drawbacks of the penalties themselves.