Karim is solving the quadratic equation x2+5x−24=0

by grouping. His work is shown below. Determine the first step at which Karim makes an error.
Step 1: x^2+8x+(−3x)−24=0
Step 2: (x^2+8x) + (-3x -24)=0
Step 3: x(x+8)+3(x+8)=0
Step 4: (x+8)(x+3)=0
Step 5: x+8=0 or x+3=0
x=−8 or x=−3

1 answer

Let's analyze Karim's work step by step to identify where he made an error.

  1. Step 1: Karim rewrites the equation \(x^2 + 5x - 24 = 0\) as \(x^2 + 8x + (-3x) - 24 = 0\).

    • The error here is that \(8 - 3\) does not equal \(5\). The correct way to break down the \(5x\) term would be to find two numbers that multiply to \(-24\) (the constant term) and add up to \(5\). The two numbers that work are \(8\) and \(-3\), but this should be expressed correctly.
  2. Step 2: He groups the terms as \((x^2 + 8x) + (-3x - 24) = 0\).

    • This grouping is not valid since the first step itself was incorrect. It should have been \(x^2 + 8x - 3x - 24\).
  3. Step 3: He factorizes this expression as \(x(x + 8) + 3(x + 8) = 0\).

    • This step seems to follow from the previous incorrect step, which means if his previous step was wrong, so is this one.
  4. Step 4: He factors it to \((x + 8)(x + 3) = 0\).

    • This also follows from the incorrect factorization of the previous steps.
  5. Step 5: Finally, he finds the roots \(x + 8 = 0\) or \(x + 3 = 0\), giving \(x = -8\) or \(x = -3\).

    • These roots would be valid if the previous steps were valid, but since they stem from an earlier mistake, they are incorrect.

Conclusion: The first error occurs in Step 1, where he incorrectly rewrites the equation and splits the \(5x\) into \(8x\) and \(-3x\). The correct approach should not have added \(8x\) in the first place. He needed to adequately break down \(5x\) as \(8x - 3x\) but following the proper structure to lead towards factoring.